View Full Version : FMA Poll: Ed to hookup with who?
Scrumhalf
2004-01-26, 21:12
If FMA were to include a little romance in the series, who would you think dear Edward Elric should be together with? :)
Personally I think Edward would be best suited to Roze! Even though Roze might be a minor character, I'd hope that she might have more spotlight soon to come in the series. (And I hope Ed grows taller too lol)
Ed & Winry? Well I really do not support this couple that much, but I would have to justify my opinion once we get to see more of Winry, then maybe I might reconsider . But at the moment, I believe that there is a strong possibility that Winry and Roy Mustang might hookup! (Their age difference isn't that bad, is it?).
And lastly, Ed and his dear brother Al. I'd totally adore these two with their brotherly relationship!
Time to speculate & view each other's opinions, folks!
- Scrum.
If FMA were to include a little romance in the series, who would you think dear Edward Elric should be together with? :)
Personally I think Edward would be best suited to Roze! Even though Roze might be a minor character, I'd hope that she might have more spotlight soon to come in the series. (And I hope Ed grows taller too lol)
Ed & Winry? Well I really do not support this couple that much, but I would have to justify my opinion once we get to see more of Winry, then maybe I might reconsider . But at the moment, I believe that there is a strong possibility that Winry and Roy Mustang might hookup! (Their age difference isn't that bad, is it?).
And lastly, Ed and his dear brother Al. I'd totally adore these two with their brotherly relationship!
Time to speculate & view each other's opinions, folks!
- Scrum.
quite a very unqiue and interesting poll, as far as i know, Ed is stickin wif his automail
Well, considering that...
Roy was the one who killed her parents. (even though he was just following orders)
I don't think Roy and Winry would work, in addition to the age factor. Roy knew Ed and Al's dad, right? So he must be late 20's, at least, and Winry's what, 15?
What I'm hoping for, or at least think might happen, is Roy and Hawkeye. Hawkeye=cool. If only she were an Alchemist as well. *shrug*
Personally, I think any romance would kill this show for me. I really enjoy the strong sibling bond between ed and al..add romance into the mix.. and you just ruin a great thing IMO.
hmm...as for mustang and winry, the age difference isnt the problem...I really only see this happening in an angsty doujinshi
YuuOminae
2004-01-26, 22:04
Roy is 29. Winry is the same age as Ed.
Asakura_Y0h
2004-01-26, 22:42
Hmm... i think ed and winry make a good pair because they grew up together and stuff but I think romance in the show is bad for it.... a little crush from winry is ok but for ed to return the feelings would ruin the show cause the highlight of this anime is the strong bond between brothers... hmmm... perhaps I should've casted my vote for the brothers instead,,,
Ah, I wasn't implying that I wanted romance in the show at all. I think it's fine how it is, and shouldn't change at all. Just, if there were to be some, Roy and Hawkeye(what IS her first name?) would get my vote.
Asakura_Y0h
2004-01-26, 23:05
Ah, I wasn't implying that I wanted romance in the show at all. I think it's fine how it is, and shouldn't change at all. Just, if there were to be some, Roy and Hawkeye(what IS her first name?) would get my vote.
hahahaha.... just remember that roy won't have his miniskirt dream come true if this happens
Forsaken102
2004-01-27, 00:17
I'll second (or third, or whatever) that Mustang/Hawkeye vote. Must be the druid in me. :D
[(*Note- druid referring to nature worshipper, which refers to their names. Nothing magical in the show, or anything like that)
hahahaha.... just remember that roy won't have his miniskirt dream come true if this happens
True, very true. Maybe I should rethink this.
And, seriously, what is Hawkeye's first name? Have they even told us? :confused:
Forsaken102
2004-01-28, 12:22
True, very true. Maybe I should rethink this.
And, seriously, what is Hawkeye's first name? Have they even told us? :confused:
Nope. No first name as of yet for the Hawk-lady.
And who cares about the miniskirt thing? We all know the real reason he wants to become Fuhrer now...
diabolistic
2004-01-28, 12:52
Where's the 'Ed + Gluttony' option?
that'd be hawt.
Forsaken102
2004-01-28, 14:03
Where's the 'Ed + Gluttony' option?
that'd be hawt.
Let's just hope that on the date, Ed doesn't treat Gluttony to "Dinner"... :p
I think the flame guy will hook up with his secretary
Dark_Sun
2004-01-28, 18:05
I think the flame guy will hook up with his secretary
haha....me too
Lst2touchdasky
2004-01-28, 19:29
lol, what a stupid question- it should be who is worth for ms rockbed... her intrest in machinary is so funny- the only thing that shes missing is a soda and red eyes. asking for more would be greedy :p
I think the flame guy will hook up with his secretary
That's who we've been talking about for these last few posts... have you not read them? Her name's Hawkeye, and she's not a secretary, just a subordinate.
Seriously i tink ed will be more worried about his height and brother more than the these issues :D
Zelgadis
2004-01-28, 22:29
I think Winry has a crush on Edward.. Though she could just be feeling sorry for her childhood friend. A little romance never hurt anyone. I am hoping that it is love and not just caring for a friend.. We shall all see in future episodes. :cool:
I think Winry has a crush on Edward.. Though she could just be feeling sorry for her childhood friend. A little romance never hurt anyone. I am hoping that it is love and not just caring for a friend.. We shall all see in future episodes. :cool:
what?! romance hurts everyone! I say keep it out of the show and save it for the smutty fanfiction.
Lst2touchdasky
2004-01-30, 02:22
I think Winry has a crush on Edward.. Though she could just be feeling sorry for her childhood friend. A little romance never hurt anyone. I am hoping that it is love and not just caring for a friend.. We shall all see in future episodes. :cool:
She probally is just intrested in him for the moment because of his unique automail arm and leg because of her machinery fetish. So even though they might hook up she'd probally break up w/ him and run of w/ that one rebel automail dude after ed gets his organic parts back. And that just leaves ed all alone((al runs of roze :p)) so your idea ties into Tzu's... kinda
what?! romance hurts everyone! I say keep it out of the show and save it for the smutty fanfiction.
I think Winry has a crush on Edward.. Though she could just be feeling sorry for her childhood friend. A little romance never hurt anyone. I am hoping that it is love and not just caring for a friend.. We shall all see in future episodes. :cool:
I agree. A little romance wouldn't hurt. I would love to see Winry and Ed hookup or at least acknowledge their feelings or maybe go a few dates. It’s also painfully obvious both have crushes on each other but don't really know it yet. Maybe it’s just too early for them to start thinking about that kind of stuff, after all their still kids.
OFF TOPIC
Does anyone know what happened to Rose/Rosa? (SP) The last time I seen her was when she was hiding out with some kids in a church or some building, and soldiers were asking them where the rebels were hiding. Can someone clear that up for me?
Asakura_Y0h
2004-01-30, 04:02
I agree. A little romance wouldn't hurt. I would love to see Winry and Ed hookup or at least acknowledge their feelings or maybe go a few dates. It’s also painfully obvious both have crushes on each other but don't really know it yet. Maybe it’s just too early for them to start thinking about that kind of stuff, after all their still kids.
OFF TOPIC
Does anyone know what happened to Rose/Rosa? (SP) The last time I seen her was when she was hiding out with some kids in a church or some building, and soldiers were asking them where the rebels were hiding. Can someone clear that up for me?
Roza was actually still in that town... awww..... what's its name...... man.... ermm....she's still at that sun god town place.... the place where the military was fighting off rebels was at the first town in the first ep of FMA.... does that clear thing's up????
hmm.... acknowledge feelings .... don't know about that one... maybe at the very end would be sweet but not now definitely....
Ookla The Mok
2004-01-30, 05:02
And, seriously, what is Hawkeye's first name? Have they even told us? :confused:Her name is Riza Hawkeye. (Yes, spelled that way.)
Fujiwarano SaI
2004-01-30, 08:29
Good God! Not Ed and Al! that is just wrong.... shame on you for writhing such a thing!
Leo_Otaku
2004-01-30, 19:28
I say Ed and Winry because they probably like each other :)
I remember when Ed was writing a letter to her, Al was going to say somthing ^-^"
Sharkus-kun
2004-01-31, 20:26
I personally think Al and Winry would end up together more than Ed and Winry, providing Al returns to his normal body. Ed'll probably end up with some character they haven't even met yet.
Forsaken102
2004-01-31, 20:54
Nah, I'm all for Ed and Roze... Maybe I just like being different, but.. that's me.
I feel sorry for Roze loosing her BF, and Al said that Ed did what he did for her sake..
And besides, I think Winry'd be more intrested in Al (even after getting his body back, for having the unique experience of being a "machine"), and then Ed could hook up with Roze (Who I like better'n Winry anyway)
Then, everyone's happy!! :D
Scrumhalf
2004-02-02, 03:02
I guess Ed & Winry have the uppermost hand here now :P
http://members.optusnet.com.au/linhtq/edwinry.jpg
Cute couple huh? :D
I guess Ed & Winry have the uppermost hand here now :P

Cute couple huh? :D
Got that screenshot from ep17 eh...
Yeah they make a great couple in a few years.
Lst2touchdasky
2004-02-02, 09:05
I still think she just obsessed w/ his machinery and when he gets his human parts back shes gunna leave him for the ex-rebel-general dude w/ the automail arm ;p and of course AL gets Roze
Scrumhalf
2004-02-02, 19:58
I still think she just obsessed w/ his machinery and when he gets his human parts back shes gunna leave him for the ex-rebel-general dude w/ the automail arm ;p and of course AL gets Roze
No one cares about your cruel mind sir. :P
'Ex-rebel-general' dude?
Scrum
Episode 17 was the perfect clue that Ed and Winry -wont- get together. She was in a tubetop the entire episode and not so much as a hint that Ed was in any way attracted to her or liked her more than a friend
Sakura-chan
2004-02-02, 20:15
*Sakura starts to look for FMA shonen ai fanfictions* I want that doujin now! Nyan. X3
Lst2touchdasky
2004-02-02, 20:43
Cruel mind? NO one cares? ouch...
ZeppelinJ0
2004-02-09, 23:20
Personally I LOVE Winry, she's so cool!!!! I think with the attitude of Ed and the quirky personality of Winry, it would be a pretty hysterical couple ;p
Winry and Ed, hands down! Roze is too soft and weak(not compatible) and Al is too...uhm...much of his brother??
WInry was there when Ed and Al first lost their bodies and was there through the earliest and at the most deciding stage of their lives. That and you can tell she has a strong personality that can math Eds and is just as cute and quirky. That and child hood buddies usually mesh well together! :D
Asakura_Y0h
2004-02-10, 22:25
*Sakura starts to look for FMA shonen ai fanfictions* I want that doujin now! Nyan. X3
sorry if this is off topic but what are "shonen ai fanfictions" and "doujin"???
Leo_Otaku
2004-02-10, 22:40
As I think I have said places. Ed has way too much on his mind to think about romance at the moment since he is the state alchemist and "all". I think Al is more laid back and thinks more about it like episode 10. Ed seemed mad that Al was caught up with the romance. My guess is in the future since I think that he doesn't notice her feelings (I think Winry likes him).
Shonen ai- isn't this like yaoi stuff....if i'm correct discusting
doujin- is fan made comics that are based on animes and such that aren't real stories they are fanfic mangas so to speak. Underground comics so to speak.
hmm. i'd say if there was it'd be w/ winry, unless there's another to be introduced later. Ed 'n' Al will be together though, as brotherly love and all that (and nothing more, either).
agreed.... most likely winry..... i mean who else would really like ed hahaahah.... lol brotherly love is just stupid.. i wonder who actually voted for ed and al, :D
:+:Fr0stN0va:+:
2004-02-11, 20:26
If FMA were to include a little romance in the series, who would you think dear Edward Elric should be together with? :)
Personally I think Edward would be best suited to Roze! Even though Roze might be a minor character, I'd hope that she might have more spotlight soon to come in the series. (And I hope Ed grows taller too lol)
Ed & Winry? Well I really do not support this couple that much, but I would have to justify my opinion once we get to see more of Winry, then maybe I might reconsider . But at the moment, I believe that there is a strong possibility that Winry and Roy Mustang might hookup! (Their age difference isn't that bad, is it?).
And lastly, Ed and his dear brother Al. I'd totally adore these two with their brotherly relationship!
Time to speculate & view each other's opinions, folks!
- Scrum.
been ages since i posted but ne way wth where di you get the idea of ed and roze??? isn't she like dead ? well it looked as if in one of the episodes she would have been killed, i would go for ed and winry, i think they get on really well and i think she does like ed, wth roy mustang and winry? no way, more like mustang and the lieutenent she seems to like him sho yea i dun know where you got your ideas but i guess its all possible since this is anime :D
been ages since i posted but ne way wth where di you get the idea of ed and roze??? isn't she like dead ?
That and last time Ed saw Roze, he sorta destroyed her beliefs, which was all she had. I wouldn't b to crazy to fall head over heels in love with a kid who did that for me..
ShadowLady
2004-02-11, 22:44
It is so obvious winry is in love w/ Ed.. I do hope there will be some more subtle hints but no need for the series to get all lovey dovey for me.
hobobaggins
2004-02-12, 00:40
It is so obvious winry is in love w/ Ed.. I do hope there will be some more subtle hints but no need for the series to get all lovey dovey for me.
WINLY!!! go winly!
they both like each other!!!
.... i could use some romance... but not overly much.
but why? winly has already stuck her thing in ED (automail) ... well... inappropriate. i will stop there. :topicoff:
ShadowLady
2004-02-13, 21:35
Ed and Lust, now that would be interesting.
lol lust...... now thats just getting carried away.....
i reckon al and that chick with the cow...
ShadowLady
2004-02-14, 04:42
lol lust...... now thats just getting carried away.....
i reckon al and that chick with the cow...
Think about it, it might be in lusts power to make people fall in love with her.
agreed.... most likely winry..... i mean who else would really like ed hahaahah.... lol brotherly love is just stupid.. i wonder who actually voted for ed and al, :D
tch...I did. Honestly, I dont think any relationship in this series is going to be stronger than Ed and Al's brotherly love
The Faction's Lord
2004-02-14, 05:06
That and last time Ed saw Roze, he sorta destroyed her beliefs, which was all she had. I wouldn't b to crazy to fall head over heels in love with a kid who did that for me..
Maybe he did destroy her beliefs, however, I think she would be thankfull for showing her the truth instead of living a lie. That's just personal opinion though. Also, I do think that Winry just likes Ed for the arm and leg. I think it's quite obvious that Ed like Roze, so that's where my votes going.
Maybe he did destroy her beliefs, however, I think she would be thankfull for showing her the truth instead of living a lie. That's just personal opinion though. Also, I do think that Winry just likes Ed for the arm and leg. I think it's quite obvious that Ed like Roze, so that's where my votes going.
Hm... I dunno about this. I think most people would rather live in their dream world than the real world.
Why? One reason is they're happier living a lie. Another reason is believing their lie was not a lie.
Take a look a religion. I'll name one, Christianity, because I was one a long time ago. Somehow, the church still tries to mesh the real world and their beliefs into one life. Of course, everyone knows the church is mostly a lie but they still believe in it.
Please don't flame me. It's just the way I feel about my former religion after now being aethist.
LinChoiSin
2004-02-16, 00:09
if there must be a romance i guess it'll be between Ed and Winry but it would suck for Al cause his soul is already in an armour so it would only be fair if Al goes out with winry! Ed has more charisma so he can try his luck with Lust or even the fantom thief chick that disapeared long time ago! :)
EliteJounin
2004-02-16, 15:46
Personally, I think any romance would kill this show for me. I really enjoy the strong sibling bond between ed and al..add romance into the mix.. and you just ruin a great thing IMO.
hmm...as for mustang and winry, the age difference isnt the problem...I really only see this happening in an angsty doujinshi
You are right. I wouldnt like them adding a romance in an anime like this. Its the same as Naruto even though he likes Sakura. There's no romance and if there was. It would mess up the series. But a little imagination cant hurt.
You are right. I wouldnt like them adding a romance in an anime like this. Its the same as Naruto even though he likes Sakura. There's no romance and if there was. It would mess up the series. But a little imagination cant hurt.
I agree, considering that this show has some heavy stuff in it already -- Ed or anyone in the show actually (besides Lt. Col. Hughes' Infinite obsession with his daughter) hardly has time for a love for anyone in particular. Far too distracting from the already deeply dug-out plot. But if there even was to be a hint of romance its WInry. Roze -- ha! No way. Ed expressed how he hated the way she threw herself at her so called God. That and shes too naiive for someone like him anyway.
LinChoiSin
2004-02-17, 00:06
i wouldn't mind a bit of romance if it fits the story well but i really don't know how they could insert a real love story into the plot without slowing the pace.
Lst2touchdasky
2004-02-17, 00:45
In your opinions, do you think the missing bolt in ed's arm will stregthen or weaken eds/winry relations
dreamless
2004-02-17, 11:55
I want to vote "Ed with Roy Mustang"... or maybe Hawkeye...
NightWalker XI
2004-02-21, 08:32
Definetly Winry, and why did you even put Roze in there, she is a paethetic character, when Ed told her the truth she whinned about why would he want to take hope jsut cause the hope they had was fake, why would anyone want fake hope, I hate her...grrr
Why is Roze included here? She is a minor character who probably won't be appearing any more. IMO Winry with Ed and Mustang with Hawkeye would be good. :heh:
how do u know roze isnt going to be in there later?????
u never know.... edward might go and save the bitch......
ed rosa and al + winry make a good combo I think. Besides Al needs some one to polish his thingie too.
of course I voted for Winry she knows him about his whole life so ..
wtf screw you with your roze she's a bitch :p maybe he has to save her another time but I think she is a minor of a minor character she only has been in one episode and later while she was protecting the children bwah
no winry has my vote * i have seen till ep 19 *
ED has to go back to let his arm fixed she forgot a screw !!! * she = Winry ;)
for those who were woundering what Hawkeyes first name is its Riza
winry is so hot.....
Mmmmm
Iori Branford
2004-02-25, 23:06
Psiren makes me wet.
Rheinhard
2004-02-26, 00:01
One small problem with the Ed & Winry theory: what do you suppose will happen when Winry eventually figures out that Ed's boss at the State Alchemist Ministry (the Flame Alchemist Roy Mustang) murdered her parents?
Might put a bit of a chill on the nascent relationship, dontcha think?
Scrumhalf
2004-02-26, 02:03
One small problem with the Ed & Winry theory: what do you suppose will happen when Winry eventually figures out that Ed's boss at the State Alchemist Ministry (the Flame Alchemist Roy Mustang) murdered her parents?
Might put a bit of a chill on the nascent relationship, dontcha think?
Hmm..
Yes, Winry will eventually figure out about Mustang and his responsibility towards her parent's murders, but that DOES NOT mean that something could spark from these two. (Well, I have changed my mind alot now have I? I was a Winry/Mustang fan before.). Personally I think this would even strengthen relations between Edward & Winry; perhaps Ed would give Winry a shoulder to cry on, & something will blossom from there ;) . As for Mr. Mustang, I'm sure something is already going on with him and Riza Hawkeye - they are perfect for each other, even though they are comrades :P .
Scrum
One small problem with the Ed & Winry theory: what do you suppose will happen when Winry eventually figures out that Ed's boss at the State Alchemist Ministry (the Flame Alchemist Roy Mustang) murdered her parents?
Might put a bit of a chill on the nascent relationship, dontcha think?
Why would that affect them? It is not as if Roy is Ed's relation or anything. Ed is not even loyal to Roy at this point. If anything, if Roy dies, Ed would be rolling on the floor laughing.
Scrumhalf
2004-03-24, 22:10
FMA Romance Update! :)
So far, after watching the 24 progress episodes of FMA..
Im sticking to my initial pairing of:
Edward Elric x Roze (If she comes back; hopefully as a permanant char, otherwise he's better off single :P)
Also I'm all for these pairings:
Col. Roy Mustang x Lt. Riza Hawkeye (Obvious sparks flying around ;) )
Col. Roy Mustang x Glacier Hughes (It CAN happen, dontcha think? :heh: )
Scar of Ishbal x Winry Rockbell (I want this to happen, they'd be a great couple!)
Alex Louis Armstrong x Winry Rockbell (lol)
Alphonse Elric x No-one (He's better off alone, his only intimate relationship is with Scar and his brother)
Personally I've given up my support for: Edward Elric x Winry Rockbell. It turns out that they're more like brothers and sisters rather than an item :heh: .
Cheers
Scrumhalf
NocturnalFerri
2004-03-25, 00:45
What about Al and bookworm-lady Sheska (?). :thinker: Lol. If you gotta pair him up with anyone, i say she's a good bet. She's meek and quiet and can be quite passionate (about books, anyway) . She's not *that* much older than Al. She's cute. Al would make a great "knight in shining armor" straight out of one of her books. :love:
Lavender
2004-03-25, 02:29
You ppl are way over ur heads =___=||| (Winry & Armstrong?? Roy & Hughes??? u ppl make me sick...). C'mon ppl, it's almost obvious that if there is gonna be any romance factor in FMA(which I'd like to see), it's gonna be between Roy x Hawkeye, Winry x Ed, OR possibly Winry x AL (the chances for this is slim though IMHO). It is hinted that Winry cares for the brothers alot. Are those romantic feelings or feelings as a sibling we are not certain at this point. However, we know that Ed probably likes Winry. Back in the older eps when Ed was still stayiing in Tucker's house writing a letter to Winry, he blushed alot when Nina asked "are you wirinting to your girlfriend?"...I dun see the Al x Winry things happening that much....AL looks at Winry as a sister as far as I can tell.
Mephista
2004-03-27, 11:01
Good gods... this is the first time i've seen anyone else consider pairing up the brothers, and i've actually LOOKED for yaoi/shounen ai fanfiction. Good to see i'm not the only pervert thinking about that... but in all honesty, unless this series undergoes a VERY drastic genre change, the brothers are NOT getting together romantically. ^_^; Of course their brotherly love is indestructible and is really what makes the series tick. But i don't think it has to be the ONLY kind of love in the series in order to maintain its image or mood. There's been plenty of romantic love in shounen series (naruto is a good example) without making the series itself turn "romantic." It's all in the way it's executed.
As for roze, i think edward pities her more than really caring about her. She's just another face he's run across and saved, and with all the towns he's saved so far it's almost surprising he even remembers her. She might be available to feel something for him after fully getting over her own religious conflict, but i think to call it romantic love would be misguided. She might think she loves him, but it might just be the result of her vulnerable state, what with losing her boyfriend AND her faith, and needing someone strong to cling to. It'd be too convenient, though, and she really needs to stand on her own, which she seems determined to do.
Edward and winry does seem to be the obvious canon couple, as most childhood friends in anime end up being... their feelings for each other might be sort of sibling-ish right now, but i can definitely see it changing as both of them matures a bit more. It seems winry is ahead of him in that respect, and she, being a girl, is more in touch with her feelings so i think she knows what's going on more than he does. Ed has to sort of prove himself as a strong hero, and part of the traditional "tough guy" image is hiding or denying any squishy mushy feelings like love. So i say definitely yes, but not right now. It could be in the background for the whole series and then implied with the rest of the "happily ever after" that happens at the end of the series.
Roy mustang and riza hawkeye, though, are hysterical to watch and it's also pretty obvious that something's developing there. Even if i'm wrong, though, i'd be happy because then riza defies the stereotype of a woman being placed in a predominantly male-occupied setting (the military) solely for romantic purposes.
Most of the couples mentioned would make amusing speculations, and i'm all for that, but looking realistically at the series i doubt anything else is going to happen. Al could end up with just about anyone because he's just so loving and lovable. It's hard to pick just one (or ANYONE deserving such a sweet guy), so i'll just stick to no one for now. It'd definitely have to be someone who would love him as he is now, just in case they don't find the stone, and also to sort of prove themselves. If the princess noticed the frog only AFTER he turned into a prince, i wouldn't trust her!
Amen, my friend.
Honestly, I can't believe the range of possibilities that is being presented here. Sure, the suggested pairings are by anyone's personal preference, but really now--Mustang and Winry? No offense, but I never thought that Mustang is the sort of guy to be attracted to younger girls. Sorry, but it seems to me--at least in the manner of all things observable--that there is definitely more space for something to happen between Mustang & Hawkeye than there is for Mustang & Winry. It may not turn out to be romantic but there's no doubt that the two have a developing relationship--something drawn from trust and companionship, that may actually open the doors to something that can be called romantic love.
Ed and Winry is also a good possibility in my opinion. It's just not a sure thing, like it will automatically happen. It requires development, which is quite challenging to pull off seeing where the story is currently in. But if the series would go this route, I think it will be rather implied, understated or implicitly presented--something that will be shown rather than told to the audience. After all, that's a convention quite common in a shounen series like this. I at least wouldn't be surprised.
I do, however, want to see something develop between Mustang and Hawkeye. It's probably just my personal preference, but I also think it's just symptomatic of me going for the "strong and mature" types :p
NinjaSetsuna
2004-03-29, 12:10
I was under the impression that Rose dies. It didn't show it or come out and say so, but I assumed she did.
MidoriShinobi
2004-07-09, 01:33
Is it just me, or is Winry x Ed hinted at a lot more in the manga?
Killua_Bakura
2004-07-23, 03:36
Personally... I think that RoyXEd are the best... I don't know why... I'm more towards the whole yaoi thing than Ed being het... but IF he were with a female character... I would have to say Roze... and I HAVE seen Elricest... just haven't read it...
Ombrenuit
2004-07-23, 09:52
But where is Ms. Hawkeye? She's a hottie!
dreamless
2004-07-23, 10:02
Edward x Roze looks a bit... tragic now... @_@
I'm still waiting for a Edward x Roy or Edward x Hawkeye option...
-|(aGe-BuNsHiN-
2004-07-23, 23:04
pretty late reply but personally, I think we do need some romance to a limited degree. Ed's lack of objectives other than the ones already shown is getting a itsy bit dull for me. Perhaps if they spiced things up by killing Winry or something...and Ed going berserk or w/e would be nice but there is no way in hell thats going to happen so...
Edit: I don't get why you people think Roy will go for Winry when there is a perfectly willing and beautiful lady like Riza right next to him...plus she is blond as well....
AznExzztasy
2004-07-24, 00:33
:confused: that would a little weird...seeing how his is nearly twice her age. ed and winry sound super nice! except shes taller than him :heh: :heh:
dreamless
2004-07-24, 00:41
Edit: I don't get why you people think Roy will go for Winry when there is a perfectly willing and beautiful lady like Riza right next to him...plus she is blond as well.... maybe because there are thousands upon thousands of perfectly willing and beautiful ladies around him, while Winry being the first unwilling and beautiful lady he met... I mean, if every single girl you have ever met all instantly fall for you, and you are so used to it, a girl that doesn't get attracted to you at first sight will become something "special" :heh:
Scrumhalf
2004-07-24, 00:51
pretty late reply but personally, I think we do need some romance to a limited degree. Ed's lack of objectives other than the ones already shown is getting a itsy bit dull for me. Perhaps if they spiced things up by killing Winry or something...and Ed going berserk or w/e would be nice but there is no way in hell thats going to happen so...
Edit: I don't get why you people think Roy will go for Winry when there is a perfectly willing and beautiful lady like Riza right next to him...plus she is blond as well....
Well I initally thought Roy & Winry might be a possibility in the early stages of FMA, but now that's out of the equation. Ed x Winry is a strong possibity I still stand by. Or even Ed x Roze - Roze losing her bf & her traumas + Winry might die soon after hints of EdWin become stronger = Ed and Roze meet, etc. Oh, the possibilities! :heh:
full_metal_31
2004-07-25, 11:33
If FMA were to include a little romance in the series, who would you think dear Edward Elric should be together with? :)
Personally I think Edward would be best suited to Roze! Even though Roze might be a minor character, I'd hope that she might have more spotlight soon to come in the series. (And I hope Ed grows taller too lol)
Ed & Winry? Well I really do not support this couple that much, but I would have to justify my opinion once we get to see more of Winry, then maybe I might reconsider . But at the moment, I believe that there is a strong possibility that Winry and Roy Mustang might hookup! (Their age difference isn't that bad, is it?).
And lastly, Ed and his dear brother Al. I'd totally adore these two with their brotherly relationship!
Time to speculate & view each other's opinions, folks!
- Scrum.
i don't think winry and roy will hook up cuz i dun think u already know roy mustabg killed winry's parents..so i dun think they'll ever hook up...sorry for not tellin that i might spoil it for u ppl! bai the way i'm goin for ed and winry.
dreamless
2004-07-25, 12:10
hmm... it's not an uncommon plot device to fall in love with someone who killed your family members...
anyway after the latest plot progression, I'd say it'd be nice for Ed x Roze, and maybe Ed x Lyra? ;)
LinChoiSin
2004-07-25, 23:08
Ed and Lyra would be great though i still prefer Ed and Lust :) .
I really don't see Ed as a dad so we should forget Ed and Roze!
I want it to be Ed and Roze. I knew she was going to come back into the story and have big affect on it, why else would they hint that she is still alive instead of dropping her completely. Besides in the end the story is going back to the Ishibal people.
Now that the next episode is based on Roze i think Ed and Roze should hook up, and Al and Winry should be together. I'm not sure about making sense at the momment because this show doesn't seem to hint any kind of love, relationship thing but that's what i'd like to happen anyways.
Scrumhalf
2004-07-30, 00:38
I wouldn't mind seeing an Ed x Roze result at all. Is it just me or do I see some hints of Ed x Roze during or at the end of episode 42? It's a shame that Ed won't be seeing Roze again when he said 'farewell'; or will he?
Ed x Winry I still stand firm by. Al x Winry I wouldn't mind, but it obviously won't work. Winry's a year older than Al, and I just don't see much interaction or chemistry between the two.
Just like the others have said, romance in this show would kind of ruin it but if one of the two had a crush on the other than it wouldn't be so bad. But anyways, I think Ed and Winry would be the best matching, but still, they shouldn't have any romance in it. As for the "crush on the other", it should be Winry who should have a crush on Ed because I just can't see Ed having a crush on Winry.
crazyXsunshine
2004-08-09, 10:18
well... rose was SO PATHETIC!!!!! ed deserves a better woman than that wimp... hehe like WINRY... yes but it is obvious that hawkeye likes roy... "i pull the trigger for the person i must protect" altho i guess that could be taken in a different way... BUT NO ELRICEST!
Nah. I say Ed and Izumi would be the perfect surprise. Then we could rename the series to Onegai Alchemist Teacher.
ChainLegacy
2004-08-10, 11:48
Sig would rip Ed in half.
Lets just keep it @ Ed n Winry, since thats the most natural and decent option that is left I suppose. Liza/Riza (however u want to call her) sticks with Roy, and I guess thats it. Roze/Roza (same story as Hawkeye) well, guess she stays single with her left over child and uhm who else is left then? Homunculi aren't supposed to fall in love or whatever so, imo thats the most basic sollution :p and then there is still alphonse, well since he's a walking armor atm, guess there's no need for love for him right now. Maybe ltr.
Killua_Bakura
2004-08-16, 04:57
hmm... I'm still standing with RoyXEd... but I don't mind Elricest... but like I said before, if any girl, Roze... I don't know why... maybe she needs him to help her...? I don't even know what I'm talking about... but I still think that she needs him in the sense that she's got too many problems
asriella13
2004-09-15, 10:03
:D hmm... I'm still standing with RoyXEd... but I don't mind Elricest... but like I said before, if any girl, Roze... I don't know why... maybe she needs him to help her...? I don't even know what I'm talking about... but I still think that she needs him in the sense that she's got too many problems
I totally agree with you. whats with all the Het people here? Ed and Al might get a little sick (that, and Al is an empty suit of armor so there wont be too many PWPs about those two :naughty: ) so i think Roy/ed is the best way to go. even though i'm only about 15 episodes in, there have been numerous occasions where one could say: "we know what happened that night" besides, from the episodes i've seen with Winry and Ed, they don't seem that romantic together. they could be cute but, even if they do work out in the episodes, there will always be yaoi shrines.
Ja ne mina
~A13
ps: i know you think i'm sick, but you're just closed minded
pps: Killua_Bakura (nice name btw), it's hughes daughter's third birthday, not second (thats an amazing scene tho! :D )
asriella13
2004-09-15, 10:18
Just one more point. If Roy ditches Ed, I'll have him. Have you seen him with his hair down (or even just seen him). He is soooooooooo nice.
:topicoff: i know, but I DON'T CARE. he's HOT! :fingers: :P
ja ne (again)
~A13
ps: i can see where the hawkeye X roy comes from, but where is the roy X winry? i never saw any evidence of that. how old is he (roy) anyway? I would say that the a Roy X Winry thing would be pedophilic (i think i spelt that wrong), but that would discredit my Roy/Ed view. Besides, do you know how many Severus Snape X Harry Potter pictures and stories out there? its really screwed over! :dots:
asriella13
2004-09-15, 10:21
Why would that affect them? It is not as if Roy is Ed's relation or anything. Ed is not even loyal to Roy at this point. If anything, if Roy dies, Ed would be rolling on the floor laughing.
"is not as if Roy is Ed's relation or anything"
Thats what you think
asriella13
2004-09-15, 10:30
Personally... I think that RoyXEd are the best... I don't know why... I'm more towards the whole yaoi thing than Ed being het... but IF he were with a female character... I would have to say Roze... and I HAVE seen Elricest... just haven't read it...
damn right. i think that they just cut the R/E stuff so that they didn't have to rate it R or NC-17
asriella13
2004-09-15, 10:33
Edward x Roze looks a bit... tragic now... @_@
I'm still waiting for a Edward x Roy or Edward x Hawkeye option...
THANKU! all the way for Eddy-baby and Roy. not sure about Riza tho... maybe she should stick with one of the other millitary blokes. they obviously fancy her aswell.
love the picture too.
asriella13
2004-09-15, 10:35
:confused: that would a little weird...seeing how his is nearly twice her age. ed and winry sound super nice! except shes taller than him :heh: :heh:
i know. poor ed. how tall is he accually? 5'4? 5'5? if that
asriella13
2004-09-15, 10:47
Let's just hope that on the date, Ed doesn't treat Gluttony to "Dinner"... :p
lol. thats brillitant
(this was just gonna be "lol" but aparrently replies have to be more then 10 characters long)
asriella13
2004-09-15, 10:49
I think the flame guy will hook up with his secretary
what a fool. ITS HAWKEYE AND ROY MUSTANG (ejit) :bash: and ED AND ROY ARE BETTER. i know i've said that about 10 times but i dont care! :fingers:
~A13
crazyXsunshine
2004-09-23, 20:52
mmm...
well all you edrose people should be geniuses or psychics.
mmm...
i dunno. ed is shorter than rose.
and nngggg... it's just uncool!(opinion only)
but definite ELRICXROSE ness in episode 49. ng. i don't like it.
vinhdang
2004-09-24, 02:48
For the person who stated what will happen when Winry finds out that Ed's boss is the killer of her parents
I don't know if you already know this, but she does know. Forgot what episode number it is, but she is talking to Ed and Al's father in the cemetary where her parents and his wife are, stating that she knows who killer her parents. In a later Episode, Winry sees Ed off. She demands that she braid his hair. Seems as if the fact that Roy Mustang is his boss doesn't matter to her. And anyways, what kind of love would that be if that throws her off.
Obviously, having seen everything. I can easily say Roy + Ed, Winry + Rose, Dante + Al, Hawkeye + Rose's grandmother, Your mom + me (I'm kidding on the last point. Seriously I kid... tell your mom I said hi though ;)
but definite ELRICXROSE ness in episode 49. ng. i don't like it.
Hmmm... I don't think you should take this literally or as having a romantic connotation. Dante has a way with words after all. Moreover, it lacks transition.
Personally, I would go for Roy and Hawkeye--because they're funny together.
:topicoff:-I voted Ed and Al :)
dreamless
2004-09-24, 03:38
Hmmm... I don't think you should take this literally or as having a romantic connotation. Dante has a way with words after all. Moreover, it lacks transition.
Personally, I would go for Roy and Hawkeye--because they're funny together.
Errr... you mean you would go for Ed to hook up with Roy and Hawkeye? that's some nice 3P action you are talking about, isn't it? :naughty: :eyebrow:
Errr... you mean you would go for Ed to hook up with Roy and Hawkeye? that's some nice 3P action you are talking about, isn't it? :naughty: :eyebrow:
:p :nono: Ahem..! No of course not.
(Besides, I'm sure there are already a lot of colorful doujinshi authors out there. :naughty: )
Heh, you got me on that one. I just like the thought of Roy and Hawkeye as an item in the same way I like Vess and Gram. :D
Leo_Otaku
2004-09-24, 16:05
ya ok people have your crazy fantasys thet will never happen....
Roy+Ed BAH kiss my ass.....
ED+ Winry all the way! bitch!
crazyXsunshine
2004-09-25, 09:33
hmm.
i agree.
You people are funny. I love you all. If I could I'd have your babies, and also the babies of various FMA characters. Not Termin-Archer though, he's really creepy.
Where's the Ed/Envy option? :D
No, really. Not joking ;D *reads Ed/Envy fanfiction*
But, well, Ed/Winry isn't that bad too.
mosesrecinly
2006-04-23, 21:29
:topicoff:-I voted Ed and Al :)
ME TOO! Huzzah for Elricest! :D
Spectacular_Insanity
2006-04-26, 16:39
I have trouble imagining anyone together except for Ed and Winry. I like Winry.
Soka-chan
2006-04-28, 04:32
If you're talking about what I think will happen, then definitely Winry!!!They are so obviously into each other,always anguing but caring, and the numeerous blushes.I think they look cute together, I like Winry(surprising, not many female anime characs I like)and I love Ed to pieces, and they are cute, and hot together.Also, since nothing happened, I looking forward to it even more than usual.
I hate Roze, she's annoying, stupid and weak, so I don't like her with Ed(or anyone for that matter)except if she's Lyra in reality(different ending).
But it's Ed/Al that has the most appeal to me, it intrigues me and has the most appeal-for drama, humour, fluff and loving.It's funny, but if they weren't brothers, there would be no doubt they were in love with the other.
Not mentioned, but Ed/Roy has the definity "two-hot-guys-getting-it-on" ring that's soooooo great^^
Isn't Ed x Winry pretty much canon in the manga?
Blood_Soaked_Rag
2006-04-30, 20:20
dunno........but i voted for ed and rose...all u asses are sick, talking about incest...homosexual incest even...well it sickens me that anyone could even
think about anyone but ed and the theif bitch from that sinkin city in the earlier eps...
or al could go with that {?chemira?}-spelling? chick thats half snake...mmmm nice
and limber....
or hoenheim can go back with dante...to 'try out' her body...that'd be HOT!!!
fadingwind
2006-05-01, 06:54
If there was such an option, I'd pick Roy. Because Roy/Ed is just so the best pairing in the world. It's my OTP. Much love for that. But putting my love for that aside, I would choose Ed/Winry. Because, after all, it is extremely canon. And I love this pairing too.
Soka-chan
2006-05-01, 14:55
Blood_Soaked_Rag, consensuous incest is not bad, and consensual homosexual relationships are not bad.It's just the non-con(any and all) that seems sick to me.
Neither Roze or Winry...I imagine Ed paired up with them but they just don't look right. Actually...for this anime, it seems more of an action and understanding series...without relationships, etc. But uhh, that's my opinion :D
x_Kotori_x
2006-05-12, 20:23
Ed x Winry. ^__^ Ok..Ed and Alphonse?! O_o You people are sick. Incest is fdfdfdfdfd up. K thanks :P
Spectacular_Insanity
2006-05-13, 01:45
I think its one of those "dummy line" options...
Well, for starters, I think the Ed/Rose thing COULD in theory work out. The only problem I forsee is that Rose is probably a few years older than Edo, but eh; I've dated women that are 2 years older than me. That was interesting, let me tell you o.O''
Elricest doesn't appeal to a straight male that much, but I won't bash it. I can't see it happening at ALL...but there is a large fan base for that particular pairing, so whatever.
Ed and Mustang = not happening, no way. Unless its a slash fic, it aint goin' down. Roy is what 28, 29? Ed's like 17 at the end of the anime, thats illegal o.o''
I'm personally a Ed/Win fan. The manga chapters I've skimmed over are HEAVY Ed/Winry in chap. 46+, which makes me teh happy man, yes it does. Logically, it would also make sense that those two hook up; they're close childhood friends, Winry loves to fiddle around with Ed's stuff anyways (er, his auto-mail I mean), and seriously, who besides Alo knows Edo better? That'd be the spunky blonde mechanic who has a wrench fetish.
Now...huge huge massive spoiler.
In the very last episode of the anime, some pretty heavy shite goes down, and if you look at it, lots of romantic possibilities are present. First off, Ed is killed by Envy in front of Rose and Al. The camera angle zooms up to Rose's face and we can see she is clearly distraught, HOWEVER she is not crying. She never actually sheds a single tear for Ed, but perhaps she is just in shock. She tries to run to him but is restrained by Dante. I think we can all agree that Winry would have gone to the slain Ed no matter WHAT the consequence.
Secondly, Mustang has a long drawn out fight with the Fuher/Homunculi and as he is leaving the burning mansion of the now dead Fuher/Homunculi, Col. Archer appears and fatally wounds him (or so it seems). Hawkeye ends up finding him, kills Archer, and when she thinks Roy is dead, ends up crying over his bloodied body.
Back at the scene where Ed is apparently dead, Alphonse breaks away from the transmutation circle where Dante trapped him and goes over to try and revive his fallen brother (remember, he is the new Philosopher's Stone now). He ends up succeeding and revives Ed, much to the joy of Rose. Al, however is no where to be seen...Edo panics and tries to bring Al back, as he concludes the Gate took his metallic body as an equivalent exchange for his rebirth. He also ends up succeeding, but now HE vanishes. The conclusion comes from Izumi, actually, that there just is no way for a human to be brought back to life, even with the Philosopher's Stone.
As the anime comes to a close, we see that Mustang did indeed live, and who else but Riza Hawkeye is nursing him back to health. She even feeds him a chunk of fruit. :) Before the scene changes, Mustang lovingly strokes Hawkeye's hair and says something along the lines of "The world is beautiful because it is imperfect," implying that her imperfections make her all the more lovely (she's distraught that she couldn't save Mustang before Archer got to him).
The scene switches to the train station at Rizenbool as a train pulls out with "someone" in it that promised Winry that he would come back with "someone" else and that they would be together again. Winry makes him promise to bring the other person back and that she'll make the ultimate auto-mail for him. Sheesh, hope I didn't just give away the WHOLE ending there..
In any case, I think that with that in mind, it makes lots of possibilities appear. Roy/Riza is almost guaranteed, but Al/Winry and Ed/Winry are still big "ifs." Ed could very well be with either Rose or Winry, but I still think Ed/Winry is the most logical, based on the way certain people react to the ending sequence of events. Damn, that was long and drawn out. Phew.
Soka-chan
2006-06-27, 20:21
Actually, this is gonna sound strange, but i don't see Ed with anyone.
Roze's too quiet, calm and traditional in every sense of the word for an active, loud, brash and very open-minded person like Ed.
Winry is too like a sister to him-I'm talking about the anime here, guys, cause in the manga Ed/Winry is more than implied-it's completely in the open now. Other possible het pairings-Noa-it's the same as Roze: she's too traditional and weak for a strong willed person like Ed. The only girl with strong will between this ladies is Winry(I think we can say she has too much of a storng will for him, hehe)
As for the other pairings...I love both of them as a fangirl, but I don't see them happening. Roy/Ed, for obvious reaons: they can't stand each other(that's not to mean they're enemies, but they don't regard the other as a friend, much less something else. Al/Ed is very beautiful, and I could see it happening if the world were more open-minded, bt as it isn't, it's not gonna happen. But if they weren't brothers and guys, this pairing would be absolutely cannon-it's obvious that the most beloved person for each of them is the other.
Maybe there's something between Hiedrich-spelling?- and Ed...?(not being siblings but being roomates...)
But in the end, I just see Ed alone. I see him above almost everyone else in courage, thoughts, feelings, beliefs, rate of maturity(by age comparisson) and intelligence. He's way too above almost all of the characters in all this aspects-except perhaps his father and Dante-obviously out of order(though I actually like the pairing of Ed/Dante in a very sick and twisted way of repeating history...)
I agree. A little romance wouldn't hurt. I would love to see Winry and Ed hookup or at least acknowledge their feelings or maybe go a few dates. It’s also painfully obvious both have crushes on each other but don't really know it yet. Maybe it’s just too early for them to start thinking about that kind of stuff, after all their still kids.
I agree it wouldn't hurt for just a little romance.
missinterception
2006-08-30, 13:20
I think Ed will eventually have a romance with Roze, seeing how is that he saves her so many times. Although I prefer WinryxEd, Ed seemingly saves Roze countless times, and this may prove their relationship to be. I think Ed and Winry may just stay friends because of their childhood together. They're best friends, and it'd probably be akward if they had a romance together.
Forget-Eden
2006-08-31, 01:29
I personally depsise the het couples in this show... I have NO idea why. The only one I can stand is RoyXRiza, but personally I think RoyXMaes is better :P!
If I had to choose one of those votes, I'd say EdXAl... Just no Armourcest please *cringes* it's nastay xD!
I really hate EdXWinry... I don't understand why people like her. *Falls over*
:naughty: Is there anything to dislike about her in particular ?
Winry Rockbell
WTF... 37 of votes for Alphonse O_O... WTF
deaddeath
2006-09-23, 11:15
If FMA were to include a little romance in the series, who would you think dear Edward Elric should be together with? :)
Personally I think Edward would be best suited to Roze! Even though Roze might be a minor character, I'd hope that she might have more spotlight soon to come in the series. (And I hope Ed grows taller too lol)
Ed & Winry? Well I really do not support this couple that much, but I would have to justify my opinion once we get to see more of Winry, then maybe I might reconsider . But at the moment, I believe that there is a strong possibility that Winry and Roy Mustang might hookup! (Their age difference isn't that bad, is it?).
And lastly, Ed and his dear brother Al. I'd totally adore these two with their brotherly relationship!
Time to speculate & view each other's opinions, folks!
- Scrum.
I really think that Roze and Edward really should be together, She doesn't care what color he is. Fat, giant whatever... and I couldn't blame her He's hot with double T's at the end. And Roy and Whinry really need to hook up
The Patriot
2006-09-23, 18:25
I would think that Ed and Winry would be a good relationship,it would be interesting..
..::Hacker::..
2006-10-08, 04:06
I would have to say that Ed and Winry belong together because the've known each other for like ever
Kilala642
2006-10-08, 04:30
First off her first name is Riza and second is I think Roy and Riza Hawkeye would be great together and same with Ed and Whinry. I also see where the Ed and Rose romance would work but she has a kid in the last season!!!!
..::Hacker::..
2006-10-08, 04:32
I would also say that the Rose and Ed would be good. I just looked at fanfiction.net and found alot of romance fanfics about those two
shimplicity
2006-10-10, 07:36
Ed and Winry looks good together and if you had notice that they cared for each other a lot more than childhood friends. In the anime, i think the movie showed the most how much Winry loves Ed.
I think the subtle hints of Ed X Winry is just right for the anime because the main focus is the brotherly bond and their purpose has a much higher priority than a blooming romance.
However, I would love to see more Riza X Roy action because they are adults and thus, it's just natural for them to have love scenes as compared to Ed and Winry.
And so, I didnt vote because there wasn't a Riza x Roy option and who Ed ended up with is a little premature and out of point with regards to this storyline anyway.
Ryuji Kuro
2006-10-10, 14:36
I think that Ed and Winry would be the most likely choice.
..::Hacker::..
2006-10-12, 17:09
I have to say that Riza and Roy belong together along with Sheska and Louis Armstrong.
What's weird I think is that alot of people at my school says they like Ed and Roy.
I'm not really into yaoi, but I guess it's pretty good from what my friends said. It sounds like an interesting relationship between Ed and Roy
Story wise Roy and Ed makes as much sense as Sheska and Louis Armstrong
emothekat
2006-10-14, 11:53
I think Roze-san is kinda a wh*re and the EdxWinry thing is to cliche'
But I totally love EdxAl
joke
I think he should meet a girl on a journey of his and fall in love even though he trys to distance himself from people and fall in love, seperate, and remeat somehow in theyre early adult years ^_^
I'm just a romantic like that ;P
I think Roze-san is kinda a wh*re
I dont know what you are smoking but must be pretty good stuff....
I think he should meet a girl on a journey of his and fall in love even though he trys to distance himself from people and fall in love, seperate, and remeat somehow in theyre early adult years ^_^
I'm just a romantic like that ;P
I think you managed to miss Winry in the same place where you figured out that Rose is a whore.... Chances of Ed confessing anything to Winry allready are next to none, anyone else is a lightyear below zero.
emothekat
2006-10-15, 18:48
It sounds like an interesting relationship between Ed and Roy
ew
never never never never no
..::Hacker::..
2006-10-20, 18:44
ew
never never never never no
You would've had to hear my friends and how they persuave you into things. I can't stand Yaio but acually alot of people like that pairing. (3 of my cousins agree with it though)
Edward & Roze: No thanks. Roze was kinda mean to Edo in the first episode.... and she made a comeback in epiode 50/51, but Dante was controlling her body....
Ed & Winry: It'd work out... but it's not exactly my favourite pairing, either....
Al & Ed: TWINCEST! SQUEE!!! Ahem >.>
When I think of Winry I think of the dub version and she just pissed me off in the dub. I watched the last quarter of the seires in subs and Winry wasn't as annoying in the sub, but the damage from the dub has been done. That why I say Ed and Ross. No I'm ging to go have an anurism from that Ed and Al option
o_0! WTF!?!?!?!?
hagane no kaizoku
2006-11-07, 22:42
Why do some fangirls get turned on by incest? I really don't get it.
My favorite FMA pairing fics I've read involve homunculi, but that's probably because I've spent a good deal of time looking for good ones. I've read several good Lust x Scar fics and a really nice and sad Sloth x Hoenheim. I also like Roy x Riza and Sheska x Havoc. Think about that last one - Sheska's a cute, smart, funny girl with a good personality, she just doesn't date (much? at all?) because she's a dork. Havoc keeps getting dumped because he's a dork. They're perfect together.
horsdhaleine
2006-12-02, 05:14
agreed.... most likely winry..... i mean who else would really like ed hahaahah.... lol brotherly love is just stupid.. i wonder who actually voted for ed and al, :D
i did. they like each other too much.
Queen Izayoi
2006-12-04, 11:23
Winry and Ed would look mad adorable lol Besides, I can't even see Ed and Alphonse together
MadHatter_Tamaki
2006-12-06, 15:13
Elrist...><
I think Ed would be great with Winry even though he ...nevermind XD
but him and Roze? O.o that is something I've never thought of
buymefood
2006-12-21, 21:18
Ed & Roze: Eh, didn't really pique my interest imagining the two together. Roze annoyed me anyway.
Ed & Winry: Classic pairing! It's always the childhood friends who turn into something romantic sooner or later! Even though it looked kind of one-sided, they both knew they liked each other :)
Ed & Al: WTF? That's gross/incest/baaaaaaaaaaaad
fullmetalMonkey
2006-12-26, 00:12
Ah, I wasn't implying that I wanted romance in the show at all. I think it's fine how it is, and shouldn't change at all. Just, if there were to be some, Roy and Hawkeye(what IS her first name?) would get my vote.
riza and you call yourself a fma fan:mad:
fullmetalMonkey
2006-12-28, 01:15
Personally, I think any romance would kill this show for me. I really enjoy the strong sibling bond between ed and al..add romance into the mix.. and you just ruin a great thing IMO.
hmm...as for mustang and winry, the age difference isnt the problem...I really only see this happening in an angsty doujinshi
n maybe for you I think some romance would do good for basiclly a actoin packed anima don't get me wrong i love it
fullmetalMonkey
2006-12-28, 01:25
I still think she just obsessed w/ his machinery and when he gets his human parts back shes gunna leave him for the ex-rebel-general dude w/ the automail arm ;p and of course AL gets Roze
correct me if i am wrong didn't he get killed
ShaiElric
2007-05-10, 20:02
I am a totall Edward Elric Fangirl but him and Winry make a cute couple!!
It doesn't make sense and its really confusing how I feel about Ed hooking up with someone!
EdwardSantheMighty
2007-06-06, 03:31
I guess I'd say rose...but don't forget rose already..had...a certain something...I mean sheesh she has a baby.
KiraYamatoFan
2007-06-10, 03:31
Ed & Winry: Classic pairing! It's always the childhood friends who turn into something romantic sooner or later! Even though it looked kind of one-sided, they both knew they liked each other :)
I'd go with them any day, it's too bad nothing much was given for them in the anime. Hopefully, the manga should tell otherwise about these two. ;)
_WinryXEdward_
2007-06-10, 10:04
Winry! Totally hey look cute together!:)
kazune-kun
2007-06-10, 22:01
ROSE is just .. O_o Theres something about her that bugs me.
WINRY x ED! FTW :D
_WinryXEdward_
2007-06-11, 15:17
yep, rose is ummm just sorta weird, she has pink hair and brown hair and yeah. and a BABY!
midnightlumina
2007-06-14, 08:20
Winry wins... Genetics would never lie to us (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gvFaeaNr4No&v3)
mcruz1014
2007-07-17, 10:23
yep, rose is ummm just sorta weird, she has pink hair and brown hair and yeah. and a BABY!
and a rape baby at that (not really sure on that, but they kinda imply it, don't you think?)
XileXKing
2007-07-17, 18:38
Those 2 would be the hottest couples <3 =33 (^_^)b
mcruz1014
2007-07-17, 21:12
personally, i want to see ed and winry together, but ed seems to be way too attached to al to notice other girls...........winry so obviously loves him, yet ed can't (or rather, won't) make any attempt to notice or acknowledge her
I think a shot of yaoi-love is exactly what this show's lacking.
lilmisscoopie
2007-09-03, 14:14
Anime never seems to have a lot of romance in it does it? Ah well. That's what we have fan fiction for I guess :) I think Ed was meant to be with Winry.
I was gutted when Winry couldn't go with them in the movie. I think there was a hint something could have blossomed between them when Ed blushed as Winry hugged him :)
marijolee
2007-09-03, 15:47
Ed and Winry...
Roy and Riza...
But seriously...the romance would kinda ruin it...but, a little would make me happy.
EdAnnoyingOlderSis13
2007-09-04, 05:26
*is hold back her younger brother Ed who is annoyed and wants to kill the poeple who think he should go with someone other then Roy*Ed goes with Roy you nimrods*Ed finaly calms down and glares and goes back to his boyfriend:It's that love hate thing,they hate but they love each other.Get it.Got it.Good.Have a nice day.Good bye.* skips off to take pictures of roy and ed to drool at the yaoi goodness.*:D
Raider1379
2007-09-04, 20:27
In the anime, the most likely choice would be Ed/Win. But, the anime focuses more on the bonds of the two brothers. It is implied at certain times that there are feelings between the two, but NO WHERE near the amount that is shown in the manga. If any one is interested in the Ed/Win pairing, i recomend reading the manga, altough its different from the anime, its just as good and is still ongoing. Getting back on topic,
In the OVA where it shows Ed 2005, u can see his grandkids, and one of them looks exactly like winry. One possiblitiy is that Ed probably married the winry in our world. Another is that Winry crossed over to our side. I say this cus Ed still has his automail, and i really dont think hes gonna stay the same hiegh as he was during the anime.
Well, thats my 2 cents lol
marijolee
2007-09-18, 23:15
In the anime, the most likely choice would be Ed/Win. But, the anime focuses more on the bonds of the two brothers. It is implied at certain times that there are feelings between the two, but NO WHERE near the amount that is shown in the manga. If any one is interested in the Ed/Win pairing, i recomend reading the manga, altough its different from the anime, its just as good and is still ongoing. Getting back on topic,
In the OVA where it shows Ed 2005, u can see his grandkids, and one of them looks exactly like winry. One possiblitiy is that Ed probably married the winry in our world. Another is that Winry crossed over to our side. I say this cus Ed still has his automail, and i really dont think hes gonna stay the same hiegh as he was during the anime.
Well, thats my 2 cents lol
I love the manga ^^
Haha. I love it how whenever people threaten to kill her and whatnot, Ed's like "NO!!!!! DONT YOU TOUCH HER" :D
marijolee
2007-09-18, 23:16
PS - Who said Rose? What are you on people?
None of them. I hate romance in anime.
fmaangle17
2007-09-26, 00:33
ed would get with me!!!!!
Nah, I'm all for Ed and Roze... Maybe I just like being different, but.. that's me.
I feel sorry for Roze loosing her BF, and Al said that Ed did what he did for her sake..
And besides, I think Winry'd be more intrested in Al (even after getting his body back, for having the unique experience of being a "machine"), and then Ed could hook up with Roze (Who I like better'n Winry anyway)
Then, everyone's happy!! :D
I would have to agree i mean rose is way hotter then winray... however edward did kinda ruin her hope from getting her bf back... and she was pissed at him at the end of the 2nd episode so she might hold a grudge on him therefore there is no chance they hook up even though it would be good... i mean on the first episode who didnt think that ed n rose wasnt going to hook up. i thought they would after all ed liked her. but everyone seems to be forgetting Lust. i mean if she was younger and if ed made her a human then she would start to feel human emotions. and she would start to feel that she owes ed for makin her human then if she befriend him to say thanks she could easily fall for him with her new human emotion she wouldnt beable to control them cos she would have no exp. with them.... well i think it would be kewl lol im just sad i no lol
ed would get with me!!!!!
lol hahaha even though im male i can still understand what you mean... i mean i wish i had edwards hair.... i would then kinda look like him but id have blue eyes... and i would be ugly as sin cos im ugly as regardless lol. but anyway he is pretty kewl and if did look like him i wouldnt mind one bit... but what about Roy i mean i kinda like his hair too it is pretty kewl but anyway lol yeah.
If Ed would end up with anyone, it would probably be Winry.
Off topic:
Is the manga still ongoing? I hope the answer is yes. ^_^
Labien Rose
2007-10-07, 09:41
This's the most difficult question! I've thuoght about it alot, but still, I couldn't decide yet! >__< Ahhhhh!!!
I think that Hiromu-sensei will answer that's Winry, but I'm a shounen-ai fan, so that I can't choose between Roy and Alphonse! I love Alphonse more, but EdxRoy will be a very good couple, too! *dizzy*
*sigh* 'kay, for this poll, vote for Al... (gomen, Roy-senpai! >_<)
EdAnnoyingOlderSis13
2007-10-08, 02:45
This's the most difficult question! I've thuoght about it alot, but still, I couldn't decide yet! >__< Ahhhhh!!!
I think that Hiromu-sensei will answer that's Winry, but I'm a shounen-ai fan, so that I can't choose between Roy and Alphonse! I love Alphonse more, but EdxRoy will be a very good couple, too! *dizzy*
*sigh* 'kay, for this poll, vote for Al... (gomen, Roy-senpai! >_<)
:flying glomp:YAY!!!:D FINALY!Another Shonen Ai fan that agrees with me!
Takuto19
2007-10-08, 18:14
Definently Ed and Winry, always loved the couple since i started watching it, would love to see them get together.
AnimeMira
2007-10-09, 07:56
I like Ed with both Rose and Winry! In the beginning of the series I wanted him to end up being with Rose, then Winry came more and more into the picture. But to be honest, I can't really choose between EdxRose and EdxWinry... It's a 50/50! =)
well, i really think ed should be with winry, but i llllove ed and al together||| hehehehe
roze is so nice, she is such a good girl
i wonder where her baby came from.....
High_Lord_Demonix
2007-11-21, 17:21
well, i really think ed should be with winry, but i llllove ed and al together||| hehehehe
roze is so nice, she is such a good girl
i wonder where her baby came from.....
she was raped by the solders invading her city..........very sad moment
but realistic couple EdXWinry those two just belong together
fantasy couple (the ones that will NEVER happen) EdXAL that would be so cute seeing them evolve beyond brotherly love.
jimbob12kirk
2007-11-27, 22:24
what?! romance hurts everyone! I say keep it out of the show and save it for the smutty fanfiction.
I completely second that idea, romance is not a part of this show now, so why make it a part ever, the show is all about ed and al's brotherly relationship, not about ed and some one else making out (lmao) and it isnt about hawkeye and wats his face. just leave it the same and it will stay the show everyone loves
Arthas1011
2007-11-28, 02:45
I say winry and elric because of my usual reasonWinry and elric always fight yet they seen to love each other sooooo.... the making of the best kind of relationships my friends
mystic210
2007-12-16, 00:02
If Ed would be with anyone in the series it would probably Winry since there chilhood friends and all
XsillyskittlesX
2007-12-16, 00:11
If there ever is any romance in the series
most likely Ed and Winry would wind up together
but yea.. romance really isn't what the show is about
CitizenGeek
2008-02-02, 05:59
51 votes for Ed and Al to hook up? They're brothers!
I think Edward was attracted to Rose in a romantic way; he just saw Winry as a very close friend. Honestly, I could never see Ed and Winry together (at least not in the anime canon, haven't read all of the manga, so it could be a different story there).
51 votes for Ed and Al to hook up? They're brothers!
That really bothers me :eyebrow:
Voted EdxWinry, even if they remain friend forever they're still a great couple...
I completely second that idea, romance is not a part of this show now, so why make it a part ever, the show is all about ed and al's brotherly relationship, not about ed and some one else making out (lmao) and it isnt about hawkeye and wats his face. just leave it the same and it will stay the show everyone lovesAgreed on that as well. Ed isn't the person who involves himself with others that much. Winry and Ed are basically family, as Winry stated that she and her grandmother are Ed and Al's family now. And Rose is still in love with her dead boyfriend, and she probably still wishes to be with him.
Cleaver-Girl
2008-03-18, 06:37
I vote for Winry and Ed because they are funny and adorable when they are together^^Besides,I think they are closer in the manga so.....
Al and Rose are cute too because they are both gentle and sweet:)
Girl_who_cried_gnome
2008-03-27, 20:49
I vote for Winry and Ed because they are funny and adorable when they are together^^Besides,I think they are closer in the manga so.....
Al and Rose are cute too because they are both gentle and sweet:)
yeah i read the manga and realized that among many other things when comparing the manga and anime, their relationship is different... they are not big things, but just blushes and completely flipping out with denial when confronted about their true feelings for one another..... well, the flipping out is mainly ed's thing :heh: while winry just shyly blushes....
suebriquet
2008-04-03, 22:59
In the manga Ed and Winry supposedly have a crush on each other, but I don't think it goes farther than that...though I haven't read too far into the manga. I think romance would ruin the show though since one of the major themes is brotherly love and the strong bond Ed and Al have for each other....though it would be interesting in a way. I've never imagined Ed to be the lovey dovey type, and him blushing in the movie when he hugged Winry was ^^;; Also, their personalities match better. It's cute how Winry hurts Ed by throwing a wrench on his head and Ed not doing anything to Winry besides getting angry. They seem to argue a lot, about milk and other topics, which is nice. It's also convenient that Winry's a good mechanic because Ed needs his automail repaired so often, so I'd say they'd make the best pair if he is to "hook up" with any of the characters.
Haha, Ed and Al just because I wouldn't be able to stand him with Winry or Rose.
I vote for Winry and Ed because they are funny and adorable when they are together^^Besides,I think they are closer in the manga so.....
Al and Rose are cute too because they are both gentle and sweet:)
I agree:)They are made for eachother
vBulletin® v3.8.4, Copyright ©2000-2009, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.