Best fansub for Mententei Loki Ragnarok

[ChibiDusk]

I am trying to find out which group did the better job on this series...
Look at these factors:

1] Video Quality
2] Audio Quality
3] Translations

Size is not an issue.

ps: I'm getting High speed on the 13th ^^

[kazuma]

i may be wrong but i think the only group that completed the serie is Seichi.
anyway they did a good job imho. go for it :)

[Keitaro]

Don't forget Xenon Fansubs also subbed the entire series also. I personally like Seichi. Thats cool now you can dl anime to your hearts content, good luck with your anime downloading. :P

[zalas]

Don't forget Xenon Fansubs also subbed the entire series also. I personally like Seichi. Thats cool now you can dl anime to your hearts content, good luck with your anime downloading. :P

mententei loki ragnarok = 麺天帝ロキRAGNAROK = the heavenly emperor of noodles: Loki, RAGNAROK

Wow, now I can just imagine all the fanfics about that :D

Anyways, the actual name of the series is Matantei Loki RAGNAROK or 魔探偵ロキRAGNAROK.

Well, I've seen the xenonfansubs episode 1 and the seichi 1-26. There was a slight encoding problem in our (seichi) earlier releases since the encoder liked to smooth out a lot of the details, but by the end of the series, I believe our encodes looked pretty good.

[Keitaro]

LOL so he mispelled it, no big deal. I hope he didn't do it on purpose. :heh:

Yeah I also remember ppl were pissed about an MLR episode Xvid encode if I remeber correctly I had to disable ffdshow in order to play the video correctly, but then you guys switched it back after a backlash of angery fans.

[ChibiDusk]

heh, of course I didn't do it on purpose *sly look*

[Ori]

I personally like Xenon's fansub more. Seichi version doesn't run smoothly on my computer.

[Zoya]

I liked both versions pretty well. If I remember correctly, Xenon's does have a large font size, and I found it to be a little bit distracting at some points, but would be good if you watch on a really large screen. Seichi has some great info on the mythology at the beginning of some episodes.

Just a note: I archive onto DVD, and I actually had to get a mix of both groups to fit all 26 episodes onto one disc.

[Eye_V]

I have watched both the Seichi and Xenon Fansubs, and think that both of them did a good job. However, I prefer the Xenon version, just because their English is a bit more fluid, and their explanations are also quite good. :)

[K_R]

There was a slight encoding problem in our (seichi) earlier releases since the encoder liked to smooth out a lot of the details, but by the end of the series, I believe our encodes looked pretty good.

zalas should mention that the encoding was done by a new encoder on episode 8 onwards, hence the change in quality.

I too believe the seichi encode has good video quality ;)

For the record, I though the font on seichi's rag was a bad choice.

[Sakaki-]

I liked X-F Version the Best, Cause their encode quality was consistent.
Good editing, This includes good notes About Norse myth Reference too.

X-F's Version does feel more thought over.
Like i said erlier they did more Norse myth research, And they used the real norse names where they fit in good.

Seichi's version was not bad but X-F had a clear edge over Seichi with good consistent editing and consistent encodes.

[ChibiDusk]

Thanks for the info ^^

[tweekgt4]

sorry.. edited.

[Jenichan]

can anyone help me get matantei eps 1-7 by seichi?

i lost those but i have the rest.

i want to put it in my archive.

upload/download, snail mail?

please PM or email me.

thanks!

Um, I believe it has been licensed since this thread started.. sorry, you can't ask that :confused:

[NoSanninWa]

Um, I believe it has been licensed since this thread started.. sorry, you can't ask that :confused:
http://v2.animesuki.com/licensed.php?browse=search&query=ragnarok

Oh dear. I suppose it's time to close this thread before xris throws it onto the licensed anime graveyard thread where it will molder with the corpses of other such ill considered questions. :shudder: