PDA

View Full Version : Greed?

nobody
2004-02-16, 16:22
I just saw episode 19...and was that Greed? In that part after Ed transmuted the prison, and you see this "red room"? *_* I can't really tell if it's him because of all that red stuff @_@

[edit] Silly me, I meant "19", not "18" =P
Yebyosh
2004-02-16, 22:03
I just saw episode 19...and was that Greed? In that part after Ed transmuted the prison, and you see this "red room"? *_* I can't really tell if it's him because of all that red stuff @_@

[edit] Silly me, I meant "19", not "18" =P
Most likely its Kimberly the Mad Bomber. But I'll confirm it when I watch the episode :p
BigFire
2004-02-16, 22:10
Most likely its Kimberly the Mad Bomber. But I'll confirm it when I watch the episode :p

Seeing that GREED is nowhere near Central at this time, I'd say the money is on Kimberly the Mad Bomber, aka, the guy wearing the pseudo-Philosopher's Stone 'round his neck, who also carved an alchemist sigil in his palm.
nak
2004-02-16, 22:10
Its not Greed, his face is far diffrent.
YuuOminae
2004-02-16, 22:34
I'm pretty sure that's Greed based on the little pimp suit that guy's wearing. I haven't seen the episode itself though.

Anyway, if any of you guys read the spoilers on web-newtype, you probably know that things will start diverging from the manga. Well. Diverge again.
Yebyosh
2004-02-16, 23:46
I'm pretty sure that's Greed based on the little pimp suit that guy's wearing. I haven't seen the episode itself though.

Anyway, if any of you guys read the spoilers on web-newtype, you probably know that things will start diverging from the manga. Well. Diverge again.
Actually Ed is breaking into the 5th Laboratory.

It is Greed. The hairstyle and face are the same. Plus YuuOminae already talked about Greed's fur-lined jacket.

Kimberly was shown much earlier Ep 15 09:10-09:17 & 10:33-10:38. In the manga, he was in another prison and looked much like a grown-up Envy.


I guess this is where the anime and manga starts to diverge.

Interesting to see Scar's interactions with Marcoh's notes (not in manga, possibly for anime only). What part will Scar play in the anime? He seems to know more about the Philosopher's Stone than anyone and yet he has memory loss?
nobody
2004-02-17, 00:33
*nods* Thanks for clearing that up for me ^^ I wonder why he's all tied up...

:( I feel so behind on the story.
nak
2004-02-17, 19:32
Do you think he had something to do in experimentations pertaining to the transmutation of the Phil stone?
SilverHeimdall
2004-02-18, 09:10
It is Greed, compare the white fur on his coat in the anime episode to the coat in this image:

Warning: Huge Spoiler in the link below D:

http://fire.prohosting.com/alkarenh/fma_1.jpeg
Yebyosh
2004-02-18, 09:47
It is Greed, compare the white fur on his coat in the anime episode to the coat in this image:

Warning: Huge Spoiler in the link below D:

http://fire.prohosting.com/alkarenh/fma_1.jpeg SilverHeimdall, that is a fanart based on speculation. Though in all speculation, it could contain some bits of truth (Still, it is most spoilerful.)

If this theory has to work, it has to explain the large age gap between the Father & the Elrics. Workable theories:

1. the Father is damn virile!!! Centuries old and his sacs are still producing!
2. the Father of the Elrics is a homunculus himself! A replica of the real Father...
3. the Elric family are the final production model of homunculi!!!

Of course, has anyone considered if the Father is simply the great-grandfather of the Elrics and Scar a cousin or distant uncle?

The joys and wonders of speculation & discovery :)
phaeton
2004-02-20, 13:26
thanks to your insight on this.
from "http://fire.prohosting.com/alkarenh/fma_1.jpeg" I've only just found out that
lust, envy, gluttony and the rest of the homunculus are actually related to Edward and Al
I don't get much info on their dad though. need to get the manga...
YuuOminae
2004-02-20, 15:49
If you actually read what Yebyosh typed, then you'd understand that it was just a family tree that some fans made up. It's just speculation. Nothing more.
Blood_Soaked_Rag
2006-04-30, 19:53
yeah i thought so coz there is no logical way that follows the rest of the manga, that ed and al could ever be related to the homonculi because homonculi arent born they are transmuted and nor al of ed transmuted greed, lust, envy, gluttony, pride or wrath...but who is that big guy in the bottom left box??? i just started the manga...is that wrath???
fullmetalMonkey
2006-12-27, 00:53
If this theory has to work, it has to explain the large age gap between the Father & the Elrics. Workable theories:

1. the Father is damn virile!!! Centuries old and his sacs are still producing!
2. the Father of the Elrics is a homunculus himself! A replica of the real Father...
3. the Elric family are the final production model of homunculi!!!

Of course, has anyone considered if the Father is simply the great-grandfather of the Elrics and Scar a cousin or distant uncle?

The joys and wonders of speculation & discovery :) [/QUOTE]

no he had a phis stone and took a body of as young man