BTW, while I was driving an anime buddy home last night we got into one of those discussions and came to the conclusion that Kuroneko is probably a fan of Bakemonogatari but not Nise. I found the whole thing somewhat amusing.
That's certainly possible. I made a similar comment once on Kuroneko but with Yosuga no Sora; it feels like she wrote one half and the other half was written by Kirino who would demand all that steamy imouto sex and shit.
So then I went searching some posts with him and found this let's call it an "Okadaism"...
I once considered writing a StrikerS fanfic that would have been essentially a rip off of the Full Metal Panic Fumoffu hotsprings episode, with Vita essentially playing the role of Sousuke's over the top security system. The outlines for my original fiction projects (I never seem to get time to actually write) can have their moments too.
Haruka's rapport with the girls and his shouta-ish looks (he's one of my favourite male moe characters) are part of the appeal... but I think what really puts him into favourite list territory is how like half the girls blush upon first seeing him.
(Akira is one of the group that doesn't... which actually fits with my theory about her being one of the sharpest of the lot but she makes sure nobody notices. Remember the scene where she energetically introduces herself to Haruka? She clearly knows exactly who he is, she just took the humourous way out when he didn't recognize her to avoid an awkward situation.)