Sorry, meant to reply before, and forgot, heh. But yeah, a lot of people don't have the open mind needed to properly evaluate the series. It's human nature, though, to cling to a belief once they develop one. And no matter what evidence mounts against it, they'll cling that much harder.
That's why you get people trying to pass opinion off as fact, because they are hoping more will agree and thus reinforce their own belief. If enough people believe, it becomes a sort of fact. That's why I try to nip it in the bud when I first see it. May piss some off, but I refuse to allow the real truth to be buried.
About madoka,Just want to say that while I thought you were being a little paranoid on the whole "people trying to pass off opinions as fact" thing,I'm being proven wrong as I read more and more posts,so yeah,I take that back lol