Yes, yes indeed! iM@S is great! Solid is a wonderful word for it ... I was originally expecting very little but brainless fanservice to the extreme, but it turned out to be very wholesome and realistic, looking into the lives of an up and coming idol agency's members. I find the idols to be charming and endearing at the same time. It's actually quite refreshing imo.
As for poor Shu ... good take on his being a more realistic portrayal of modern day otaku sorts. But I must admit, otaku or otherwise, the guy is still a shy and awkward teenager - and Inori's actions (whatever her real or faked motives, etc.) had to hit him hard.
I agree with you on Shu. I think he's taking a bit more hate than what's deserved. But I do have a theory on this, thanks to hoarfrost: I think that the "Yuji Everyman" character type is often an idealized representation of the modern otaku, whereas Shu is a more realistic representation. That makes Shu come off looking worse to a lot of people, whereas to me I think it makes him seem more real, and hence easier for me to feel sympathy for.
Oh, and on a separate note, I recently picked Idolmaster back up, and am up to Episode 8 or so now. It's very solid! I'm enjoying it more than I thought I would.
Part of the reason I stalled it before is that I found the cast size simply daunting. But each episode is thankfully choosing different girls to focus on, and it's gradually becoming easier and easier to tell the girls apart from one another.
BTW - totally agree with your comments in defending Shu for Guilty Crown ep 5. Must admit that I personally don't really like the "he soooooo deserved it" angle some were taking. But then maybe that's just me. Man - I felt so badly for him after Inori dropped the bomb and then he saw her going into Gai's room followed by Ayase's comments.
I know I would have been pretty hurt in that situation....
Between Chihayafuru, Mashiro-Iro Symphony, and Tamayura ~Hitotose~ this has actually turned out to be a much stronger season for slice of life/drama/romance anime than I thought it would be.
Agreed ... although I must admit that I am still kinda surprised you have not been bitten by the iM@S bug. Hard to find a better example of cute girls doing cute things airing atm imo. (In fact am listening to the Full version of the iM@S OP 1 as I type this ... grabbed from a youtube repost from Nico Nico.)
Well - everyone has their 'drothers and such!
Interesting about Tamayura ... ep 6 focused on the friendship between Maon and Norie ... had forgotten about that "building block". Maybe the second half of the season will bring in the photographer?
Thanks a lot for all the good/positive feedback on my Mashiro-Iro Symphony review. When it comes to slice of life, drama, and romance anime shows, I think we're more or less on the same page and of very similar taste.
I'm still thoroughly enjoying Tamayura ~Hitotose~, for example, there's just not a whole lot for me to say on it aside from noting the strengths that were already made clear in the first few episodes. Although I might comment on it again after I watch Episode 6.
Between Chihayafuru, Mashiro-Iro Symphony, and Tamayura ~Hitotose~ this has actually turned out to be a much stronger season for slice of life/drama/romance anime than I thought it would be. Great compliments to the very good action-oriented material (Guilty Crown, Fate/Zero, Shana III) that I just about knew would be there.
Hafta add an extra word of praise here too ... that was an EXCELLENT summary of Mashiro-iro Symphony. A good articulation of many of the things I have liked about the series and a good analysis of Uryu as well. Kudos!