No, it's cool. And funny, lol. And it fits at the moment with two-timing Madoka. I'm glad to see you realize she's deeper than Makoto Itou, though.
As for Nanoha - Yeah, the AS Nanoha community is one that sometimes scares me, lol. But I loved the movie, and I decided that it's time to fight back a bit... Vive la NanoFate Resistance! It's great to know we agree a lot on that wonderful movie.
I was kind of worried that I might be reducing Madoka to a one-dimensional caricature or something in my reviews, lol. She's a perfectly well-rounded, nuanced, lovely character and you write her excellently. I just make her out to be an unfaithful mega slut because it appeals to my fetishes. ._.
And nice work on the A's Movie thread. I agree with basically every single thing you've said in there. That forum's always been an incredibly negative little corner of AnimeSuki...