My only personal problems with the story are:
Quote:
1) Galatea's personality and her general attitude, not sure I like the direction you took her character.
|
Oh well, I've heard about this objection before. Rest assured she will enjoy more sympathetic treatment in book 2, which is currently in progress.
Quote:
2) MiriaxCid, the pairing doesn't just seem right, not sure he is a good match for Miria, which seems to reflect Helen's thoughts in the story ironically enough.
|
Ah yes, the perennial question of "Why is she with him?" I've run into this with my neighbor's daughter, who is dating a guy many think "questionable". Why? No one's certain, but there are minor complaints all the time about it. Think of it this way-isn't something like this more realistic than having the bizarre pairing of Miria & Rigardo?
You'll note that many of the claymores in the story share your doubts, but like my neighbor's daughter, the relationship endures regardless.
Quote:
3) The general power of some of the higher ranking Claymores seems understated, I'd expect the single digits to be handle 50x1 odds, easily even for the likes of Miria and Clare. The general speed of Claymores seems much greater then horses and human reaction speed imo.
|
Now, now, if you actually go back and read the story you'll notice Miata did just fine slaughtering human opposition. Miria didn't see enough combat to end your impression, although her near-awakened moment ought to end your concerns regarding her strength.
As for horses' speed being greater, I present thee my counter-evidence:
http://manga.bleachexile.com/claymor...6-page-21.html
You remember who won that race now don't you?
Quote:
Other then those nitpicks, the rest of the story looks great.
|
Glad you enjoyed it. Do you think it'd get a good reception fanfiction.net? I know some parts are controversial, but I think it'll be an excellent addition regardless.