AnimeSuki.com Forum

AnimeSuki Forum (http://forums.animesuki.com/index.php)
-   Full Metal Panic (http://forums.animesuki.com/forumdisplay.php?f=7)
-   -   Full Metal Panic? Fumoffu (http://forums.animesuki.com/showthread.php?t=10047)

kyosuke 2004-03-23 23:25

Full Metal Panic? Fumoffu
 
I've asked people around and they suggested me this anime.
Could someone tell me whether this anime is like a continuation of Full Metal Panic! ?
Would I be able to understand the series if I started watching this without watching "Full Metal Panic!" first?

Thanks in Advance,
Kyosuke

MikoKikyo 2004-03-24 00:39

No, I don't think they're related... I never watched Full Metal Panic, and when I watched FMF it didn't seem like anything was missing, it was pretty basic and straightforward...

So don't worry about it, you can understand FMF in itself.

kj1980 2004-03-24 00:51

Quote:

Originally Posted by kyosuke
I've asked people around and they suggested me this anime.
Could someone tell me whether this anime is like a continuation of Full Metal Panic! ?
Would I be able to understand the series if I started watching this without watching "Full Metal Panic!" first?

Thanks in Advance,
Kyosuke

A short, clear-direct-to-the-point answer would be: No, you do not have to watch "Full Metal Panic!" to understand "Full Metal Panic? Fmoff"

Elaboration: Though the two stories are related (characters, background details, etc.), the former revolves around action/adventure in a combat zone while the latter focuses its attention on the characters' comical life in high school.

Hence, you do not need to watch "Full Metal Panic!" beforehand to enjoy "Full Metal Panic? Fumoffu." However, a lot of my friends who haven't watched FMP! and started with FMP?Fmoff did get them interested into watching/reading FMP! in the end.

Kyuven 2004-03-24 01:35

to elaborate: FMP is based on books
the manga is based on the books+the short stories based in the FMP world
the anime Full Metal Panic! is based in the straightforward world of the novels
Fumoffu is the animation of the "filler" manga chapters and the short stories written by the original author.
the manga has an interesting way of going about it, too: Vol. 1 is mostly school comedy, vol. 2 is entirely about the events in N. Korea, vol 3 is more comedy, and vol. 4 is more plot

Slade xTekno 2004-03-24 02:12

FMP: Fumoffu? is just a bunch of happenings at school while Sousuke attended. All you need to know to watch Fumoffu? is that Sousuke grew up a guerilla fighter in Aghganistan and is having trouble adapting to the normal Japanese lifestyle. THis is explained in the first episode...
Full Metal Panic is not required. However, it is a good series you may want to see.

ff7799 2004-03-24 22:05

Quote:

Originally Posted by kyosuke
I've asked people around and they suggested me this anime.
Could someone tell me whether this anime is like a continuation of Full Metal Panic! ?
Would I be able to understand the series if I started watching this without watching "Full Metal Panic!" first?

Thanks in Advance,
Kyosuke

Full Metal Fumoffu pics up directly where full metal panic leaves off.

Kyuven 2004-03-25 01:03

Quote:

Originally Posted by ff7799
Full Metal Fumoffu pics up directly where full metal panic leaves off.

half right
almost any point of FMP? Fumoffu can take place before (or after) episode 12
episode 1 of FMP? Fumoffu actually takes place right BEFORE FMP! episode 1

roguenoir 2004-03-27 06:27

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kyuven
half right
almost any point of FMP? Fumoffu can take place before (or after) episode 12
episode 1 of FMP? Fumoffu actually takes place right BEFORE FMP! episode 1

Episodes 11 and 12 take place after FMP! 1 b/c of the brief flashback of one of the ending episodes of FMP1. It would make sense that the sub is undergoing maintenance due to the whole incident at the end of FMP1. The other episodes could have taken place anywhere.. during or after FMP1.

I'd recommend that you watch BOTH series simultaneously if you haven't seen either, preferably starting with a few ep's of FMP1.

Umbrae 2004-03-27 21:42

I did not watch FMP before watching FMP:F yet fumoffu became my favorite comic anime. Personaly, I would recomend watching a few episodes of FMP, but it is in no way nessisary.

You will just get a few jokes better, like when his partners show up for the bath house episode.

Marine-RX179 2004-05-05 18:49

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kyuven
half right
almost any point of FMP? Fumoffu can take place before (or after) episode 12
episode 1 of FMP? Fumoffu actually takes place right BEFORE FMP! episode 1

Actually you are the one that's mistaken....ff7799 was right.
Chidori only met Sosuke only for the first time in school during the episode 1 of FMP, while through the episodes of FMP? Fumoffu, it has already clearly shown her affection for him.

xKeen 2009-11-01 08:13

5 year old,but I just can't resist posting.
Still watching episode 2,and I can't stop slapping myself from the humor(can't stop laughing)

JRendell 2009-11-01 18:01

Indeed, it is very funny.

darkdarkdark 2009-11-02 18:23

Quote:

Originally Posted by xKeen (Post 2742198)
5 year old,but I just can't resist posting.
Still watching episode 2,and I can't stop slapping myself from the humor(can't stop laughing)

Yeah, FMP:F was a pretty funny set of episodes. I wish there were more though, 12 episodes seemed short.

Anyway, happy watching. Favorite episodes for me: 6 & 11

gaffer7 2009-11-02 19:34

A classic series for me, I don't think there's a single purely comedy style anime I would rank as highly as FMP Fumoffu. Actually, interestingly enough, I would likely choose to show people Fumoffu first over the original series if I was introducing them to anime, largely because I think it was much better done :)

LeoXiao 2009-11-02 20:05

Quote:

Originally Posted by gaffer7 (Post 2745541)
A classic series for me, I don't think there's a single purely comedy style anime I would rank as highly as FMP Fumoffu. Actually, interestingly enough, I would likely choose to show people Fumoffu first over the original series if I was introducing them to anime, largely because I think it was much better done :)

Yeah I think so too. However some things don't make sense unless you watch the main story. IMO the reason why Fumoffu was better was really just because KyoAni did the last two seasons.

xKeen 2009-11-03 18:43

Moving on to second raid after I finish this.I miss the other characters...

darkdarkdark 2009-11-03 19:00

Quote:

Originally Posted by gaffer7 (Post 2745541)
A classic series for me, I don't think there's a single purely comedy style anime I would rank as highly as FMP Fumoffu. Actually, interestingly enough, I would likely choose to show people Fumoffu first over the original series if I was introducing them to anime, largely because I think it was much better done :)

I disagree. I started on a few episodes on fumoffu at first, because I thought that it was the first season. I got confused later, and did not realize it was the 2nd season until episode 10. It confused me. I watched the first season, and fumoffu was a lot funnier the second time :p

Quote:

Originally Posted by xKeen (Post 2747475)
Moving on to second raid after I finish this.I miss the other characters...

I don't really miss any of the characters from fumoffu. Tsubaki was lame. Sousuke owns him hands down ;). I love TSR (episode 6,9,13 for sure). Animation was a lot better in it as well.

xKeen 2009-11-03 19:16

I meant the characters from Full metal panic!

gaffer7 2009-11-03 20:30

Quote:

Originally Posted by darkdarkdark (Post 2747499)
I disagree. I started on a few episodes on fumoffu at first, because I thought that it was the first season. I got confused later, and did not realize it was the 2nd season until episode 10. It confused me. I watched the first season, and fumoffu was a lot funnier the second time :p

Hmm, well, I showed Fumoffu to a number of my friends and even without the first season, they were cracking up over the series. I will admit, though, that I had to explain a few things to them at certain points, but that's why I'd probably show it to them, not get them to watch it themselves, as Fumoffu never gets old for me! I'm basing my opinion mainly on the fact I've personally seen far more favourable responses among people I know for Fumoffu, some really dislike the first season :confused:

darkdarkdark 2009-11-05 18:47

Quote:

Originally Posted by gaffer7 (Post 2747632)
Hmm, well, I showed Fumoffu to a number of my friends and even without the first season, they were cracking up over the series. I will admit, though, that I had to explain a few things to them at certain points, but that's why I'd probably show it to them, not get them to watch it themselves, as Fumoffu never gets old for me! I'm basing my opinion mainly on the fact I've personally seen far more favourable responses among people I know for Fumoffu, some really dislike the first season :confused:

Well, the first season was a bit of a doozy. I personally liked the first season the least out of all. First of all, only the first few episodes were pretty interesting, and how Kaname finds out Sousuke is a mercenary and all, then it gets pretty dull. Behemoth was pretty boring, and the 3 Hamajistan(sorry for spelling) ones were a bit depressing. The first season ended terribly too, and did not offer much closure. Thank goodness for another 2 seasons.

Fumoffu is watchable because it's a comedy series. It attracts all types of viewers, and it was pretty well done.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 21:03.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.