AnimeSuki.com Forum

AnimeSuki Forum (http://forums.animesuki.com/index.php)
-   Monster (http://forums.animesuki.com/forumdisplay.php?f=38)
-   -   What rating would u give Monster? (http://forums.animesuki.com/showthread.php?t=13600)

ace firefist 2004-05-13 13:10

What rating would u give Monster?
 
I heard it was a relly good manga + anime but i still have doubts.

I hope you can enlighten me. :confused:

Kyuven 2004-05-13 13:38

it's a work of art
i almost regret watching the first episode, because now i'm caught in the stream...waiting for the next episode *fetal position*

musouka 2004-05-13 13:45

Um, I would say it's beyond the level of OP/FMA/Naruto. That's not to say those series are bad, because they're all good series, but they're not in the same class as Monster, to put it bluntly.

Kyuven 2004-05-13 13:52

oh, i gave it a 9 btw because i almost NEVER give perfect 10s to ANY anime or manga...since i can find flaws in almost everyone of them >_<

ace firefist 2004-05-13 14:02

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kyuven
oh, i gave it a 9 btw because i almost NEVER give perfect 10s to ANY anime or manga...since i can find flaws in almost everyone of them >_<

Could any1 tell me what genre it is?

Kyuven 2004-05-13 14:37

thriller/suspense/horror

whatever123 2004-05-13 15:28

i gave it 10
solid story (not sci-fi or martial art or fantasy, if you are looking for those then monster isn't for you)
good story telling
nice character development
heavy moral and ethical consideration

Prince of Chronics 2004-05-13 17:05

though highly entertaining shows.... I do not believe that naruto/one piece/fma are 10/10 animes....

I gave Monster a rating of 10/10 ... I have only seen frist 4 episodes by ToTan... I never read the comic... just jumped into the show after all the discussion I read here... and not only was it entertaining but the plot just sucked me in completely... the suspense and directing in episode 4 was damn awesome... Monster is nice show to watch...

Mason Proulx 2004-05-13 18:37

Quote:

Originally Posted by Prince of Chronics
though highly entertaining shows.... I do not believe that naruto/one piece/fma are 10/10 animes....

Exactly. I`d rather rate it on its own merits. I would have normally given Monster a 9, One Piece a 9 and Naruto and FMA an 8. But since we`re voting by comparison, it`s like I have no choice but to vote 10. Rating it anything less would be like saying that Monster wasn`t up to the same standard.

SoulDrinker 2004-05-13 20:29

i gave it a 7 cuz i only seen 4 eps that too soon to give a soild rating btw how many eps are their i heard 52

Ero-Sannin 2004-05-13 21:32

i dont think it should be rated yet, it doesn't have that much episodes so far, and as for OP/Naruto/FMA i give OP 10 Naruto 10 FMA 7

duskphoenix 2004-05-13 21:53

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ero-Sannin
i dont think it should be rated yet, it doesn't have that much episodes so far, and as for OP/Naruto/FMA i give OP 10 Naruto 10 FMA 7

Well the original poster mentioned the manga as well as the anime, and since the manga is complete at 18 volumes there's plenty to base a rating on. I voted for 9-10, leaning towards the 10 side of that range.

fenrihr 2004-05-14 07:55

i'd have to go w/ 9.5. i'm holding judgement for a 10/10 for a later date.

in all monster has an amazing story, almost King-like in nature.
the art style lends heavily to the mood set by the story and goes along with it perfectly.

in all, it's just about perfect.

ace firefist 2004-05-14 16:38

Quote:

Originally Posted by whatever123
i gave it 10
solid story (not sci-fi or martial art or fantasy, if you are looking for those then monster isn't for you)
good story telling
nice character development
heavy moral and ethical consideration


Is there any action? :confused:

How would you compare it to Grappler Baki? :heh:

eLstar 2004-05-14 16:59

I gave it a 9-10 rating. It's one of the best Manga/Anime I've ever read/seen.

ace firefist 2004-05-14 17:11

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dranz
I gave it a 9-10 rating. It's one of the best Manga/Anime I've ever read/seen.

So what type of anime do u like Dranz. :confused:

dreamless 2004-05-14 18:44

err.... if OP/Naruto/FMA is 9/10-10/10, I'll have to rate Monster 9378172783461824/10... :p

It's currently my second most favorite modern manga series, slightly below Berserk, slightly above Revolutionary Ludwig. ;)

(by "modern manga series" I mean to exclude things like Bird of Fire and Devilman... which is hard to judge fairly...)

ShellyKukai 2004-05-15 13:14

10!

I just finished reading the manga. I think it is comparable to a high work of literature. Very intense.
The anime looks great as well. In fact, I was so hooked after episode 3 I had to read the manga soon after and I couldn't stop until I was done reading all 18 volumes.

Jn183 2004-05-15 14:16

I give it 7 since I only watch thee anime. So, I need more to give a solid rating.

pyu 2004-05-16 08:00

I think it is far too early to rate the anime solely on its own limits.

If (and that is a very significant if) the anime production is at least 90% faithful to the manga, I would say it would definitely be one of the best anime series in Japan for a long time.

That would be until 20th Century Boys get its own anime series... :heh:


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:59.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.