AnimeSuki.com Forum

AnimeSuki Forum (http://forums.animesuki.com/index.php)
-   Midori no Hibi (http://forums.animesuki.com/forumdisplay.php?f=37)
-   -   Midori no Hibi - Comparing the anime to the manga (http://forums.animesuki.com/showthread.php?t=40568)

buymefood 2006-12-21 23:27

Midori no Hibi - Comparing the anime to the manga
 
I finished the entire manga series before the anime and the differences are EXTREMELY noticeable. First off, they left out most of the good scenes and dialogues from the manga and only included a few of them in the anime, if at all. I guess the producers wanted a more 'kid friendly' show since they didn't show Midori's childhood friend (forgot name) showing attraction to Seiji. Maybe it's just me..:confused:

chison 2006-12-24 11:43

not getting the manga?
but Midori no Hibi is really the one which making me into anime^^

whitewater_81 2006-12-28 20:36

Quote:

Originally Posted by buymefood (Post 776228)
I finished the entire manga series before the anime and the differences are EXTREMELY noticeable. First off, they left out most of the good scenes and dialogues from the manga and only included a few of them in the anime, if at all. I guess the producers wanted a more 'kid friendly' show since they didn't show Midori's childhood friend (forgot name) showing attraction to Seiji. Maybe it's just me..:confused:

lol.I really don't think it was "kid friendly" coz' there were a lot of scenes showing midori's boobs..:heh:

Chi-no 2007-01-10 05:03

I show the anime 1st then the Manga version. Both are kinda expected to me cause I know that the anime doesn't go into much details on the certain part of it. But on the Overall I like it and wasn't much of a disappointed. :)

xaquastarx 2007-02-03 18:05

I found that Midori no Hibi didn't get that addiction thing which glues me to shows like Ouran and such. It wasn't that kid-friendly and the but it was still good.

dpryciak 2007-02-03 20:39

Quote:

Originally Posted by whitewater_81 (Post 782551)
lol.I really don't think it was "kid friendly" coz' there were a lot of scenes showing midori's boobs..:heh:

Just what I was going to say!

They simplified it so that they can package it easier and sell it quickly.

whitewater_81 2007-02-04 08:59

Quote:

Originally Posted by dpryciak (Post 821722)
Just what I was going to say!

They simplified it so that they can package it easier and sell it quickly.

lol at those bastards!:heh:

Maritime 2007-03-09 14:43

I quite liked the anime although the ending was a a massive disapointment, having never read the manga I don't know the similarities and differences but it was a really fun series to watch.

Klashikari 2007-03-09 14:57

to me, it was a bit disappointing how they didn't really developped a lot the supporting characters, especially Kouta. (no hilarous ambigous Yaoi with Seiji, his devotion to Midori was kinda cut in half, seriously.)
in fact, the plot was far less cluttered by fillers, compared to its manga counterpart (that was really a good point, where the manga was really going overboard, a la Love Hina), but the critical plot devices weren't really written pretty well. (Seiji's Choice about Midori didn't have any impact in the anime, while in the manga, it was a critical dilemna, meaning an end, but also a beginning)


it was really enjoyable, but it wasn't really faithful to the original main plot.
as a side note, i felt the "Takako FULL ATTACK MODE day" in the anime was much better than its dull clusmy manga counterpart.
both versions are kinda completing each other.

Whitemoon648 2008-03-06 05:42

Ending of midori
 
ending of Midori?

Based on the wiki

Spoiler for anime ending:


then

Spoiler for manga , based on wiki:


If you look at the bold part, Shouldnt it be wrong? i mean when i read the Manga, the way i remember was ,

Spoiler for manga ending that i read:


Could some one confirm this? I just want to make sure. So does she remember or not? What is this spin of that the wiki talks about?

For wiki page http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Midori_...nly_characters.











Now another question. At the very end of the Manga , Seiji tells Midori

Spoiler for manga at the very ending:


Does any one know what does that supposed to mean :)? I have a feeling , there is something to that last statement but i dont know what is. I would really appreciate if any one could tell me.

Thanks alot in advance.

xris 2008-03-06 07:13

The ending is left open for your own interpretation but maybe it helps if you read the last chapter again (and look at the actual pictures as well as the words).

Spoiler for Manga ending:


Edit: And of course there is a 4-koma at the end of the last volume that does actually state she read the diary so I guess it isn't down to any interpretation anymore :heh:

Whitemoon648 2008-03-06 23:12

Quote:

Originally Posted by xris (Post 1443311)
The ending is left open for your own interpretation but maybe it helps if you read the last chapter again (and look at the actual pictures as well as the words).

Spoiler for Manga ending:


Edit: And of course there is a 4-koma at the end of the last volume that does actually state she read the diary so I guess it isn't down to any interpretation anymore :heh:

Thanks alot. I completely had forgotten that Midori no hibi was in this section. It had been such a long time since i last saw midori no hibi. By chance few days ago i watched a few episode again but it had been like 3 years since i thought about it. Well you should then probably merge the thread in the license section with this one too :). Sorry for the trouble :D.


Also the last pages were in japanese so i couldnt read. gotta find an english version i guess :).


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:32.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.6
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.