AnimeSuki Forums

Register Forum Rules FAQ Members List Social Groups Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read

Go Back   AnimeSuki Forum > Search Forums
Reload this Page Search Results

Notices

Page 1 of 7 1 23 Last »
Showing results 1 to 25 of 152
Search took 0.00 seconds. Search: Posts Made By: Mentar
Forum: Older Series 2009-09-30, 01:27
Replies: 2,739
Views: 495,393
Posted By Mentar
There's one interesting observation I made... in...

There's one interesting observation I made... in this thread. There's a funny correlation between how openly people advocated a "kill! kill! kill!" line during airing, and the amount of whining and...
Forum: Older Series 2009-09-28, 01:40
Replies: 2,739
Views: 495,393
Posted By Mentar
For the love of god, could you please stop being...

For the love of god, could you please stop being an ass?

YOU didn't like it, fine. We got it, around by the 19th time you told us. I'm in the VN crowd too, and I have no problem with the change....
Forum: Older Series 2009-09-27, 22:44
Replies: 2,739
Views: 495,393
Posted By Mentar
By the way: This oh soooo horrible anime is...

By the way: This oh soooo horrible anime is closing in to _Saki_ in postings on this board ;)
Forum: Older Series 2009-09-27, 22:08
Replies: 2,739
Views: 495,393
Posted By Mentar
Guys. Before this nonsense Bee Train bashing gets...

Guys. Before this nonsense Bee Train bashing gets even more out of hand. Nitro+ was fully involved in making this anime. Urobuchi Gen himself - the author of the original game - worked on the script...
Forum: Older Series 2009-09-27, 18:20
Replies: 2,739
Views: 495,393
Posted By Mentar
Aw come on, wishing them financial harm is the...

Aw come on, wishing them financial harm is the epitome of a childish reaction.

If you really have such qualms with an adjusted ending, which happens to be entirely in the mood of the show and also...
Forum: Older Series 2009-09-25, 00:14
Replies: 2,739
Views: 495,393
Posted By Mentar
Sorry guys. All I can say that with the way it...

Sorry guys. All I can say that with the way it was concluded, and after reading through the script, it was a nasty rude surprise, but an absolutely fitting ending.

For those who are mad as hell...
Forum: Older Series 2009-09-24, 21:49
Replies: 2,739
Views: 495,393
Posted By Mentar
You know what's truly macabre? The last...

You know what's truly macabre?

The last thought of Reiji was that he wanted to give Elen her laughter back (the ditzy pseudo-laughter as his sister doesn't count). Then, Reiji gets shot and...
Forum: Older Series 2009-09-24, 21:35
Replies: 2,739
Views: 495,393
Posted By Mentar
Well, wow... BeeTrain/Nitro+ will have known...

Well, wow...

BeeTrain/Nitro+ will have known right from the start that this kind of ending will leave almost everyone unhappy. So I've got to give them some kudos for having the guts to pull...
Forum: Older Series 2009-09-22, 14:50
Replies: 2,739
Views: 495,393
Posted By Mentar
Well, that was me, and I fully expected to have...

Well, that was me, and I fully expected to have another Mitsuki-Haruka kind of war break out when the crap hit the fan. Overall, particularly on this board, I'd say that we had some quite fruitful...
Forum: Older Series 2009-09-22, 10:24
Replies: 2,739
Views: 495,393
Posted By Mentar
The "she wouldn't have listened anyway" didn't...

The "she wouldn't have listened anyway" didn't happen in the anime either.



Not really. Unless you want to turn Reiji into a real bastard by making him think "hey, I love Elen, so let's gun...
Forum: Older Series 2009-09-22, 10:08
Replies: 2,739
Views: 495,393
Posted By Mentar
Well, feel free to believe that, but I'm not so...

Well, feel free to believe that, but I'm not so sure. If she didn't care, why did Cal react the way she did in the end? Besides, she believed it just alright in the other paths...

The difference...
Forum: Older Series 2009-09-22, 10:02
Replies: 2,739
Views: 495,393
Posted By Mentar
Just like I wrote to Zwei before: The...

Just like I wrote to Zwei before: The "explanation" Reiji gave incorrectly confirmed Cal's misconception. I'm not so sure that she really wanted to kill Reiji herself in the end (though this is...
Forum: Older Series 2009-09-22, 08:06
Replies: 2,739
Views: 495,393
Posted By Mentar
Jesus Christ. And YOU accuse others of being...

Jesus Christ. And YOU accuse others of being stubborn. In this scene, he didn't "explain" anything at all. He said that Cal was the stronger one, that she had the right to kill him, but that she...
Forum: Older Series 2009-09-21, 21:05
Replies: 2,739
Views: 495,393
Posted By Mentar
Let me reiterate, there WERE NO EXPLANATIONS....

Let me reiterate, there WERE NO EXPLANATIONS. Please stop peddling this line without giving an example in which episode at which timecode he explains anything.
Forum: Older Series 2009-09-21, 16:30
Replies: 2,739
Views: 495,393
Posted By Mentar
Not for everything, of course. Cal needs to...

Not for everything, of course. Cal needs to shoulder her own part of the guilt, and lord knows that's alot. But the fact is that it was indeed Reiji who first unknowingly condemned Cal to an...
Forum: Older Series 2009-09-21, 12:31
Replies: 2,739
Views: 495,393
Posted By Mentar
On another board, I've written a summary of my...

On another board, I've written a summary of my view on Cal's development in chapter 3. It might be interesting to others in understanding what's been making her tick, so here's a copy:

The key to...
Forum: Older Series 2009-09-20, 14:03
Replies: 2,739
Views: 495,393
Posted By Mentar
Well, then Wikipedia is wrong, too. Happens, you...

Well, then Wikipedia is wrong, too. Happens, you know.

Based on the situation, it's pretty clear that Cal will NOT target them in the future anymore. It's her gruff way to say goodbye. Also, it's...
Forum: Older Series 2009-09-20, 12:47
Replies: 2,739
Views: 495,393
Posted By Mentar
TJR: Er, what? Unless my memory totally...

TJR: Er, what?

Unless my memory totally fails me, your summary of the Mio path is strongly misleading. First of all, it's clear that Cal will _not_ pursue her revenge part any longer. Also, Reiji...
Forum: Older Series 2009-09-20, 11:41
Replies: 2,739
Views: 495,393
Posted By Mentar
Cal also survives in the Mio ending and ends her...

Cal also survives in the Mio ending and ends her hunt for revenge.
Forum: Older Series 2009-09-19, 22:28
Replies: 2,739
Views: 495,393
Posted By Mentar
Well... this is one of the problems I have with...

Well... this is one of the problems I have with the Elen path. The fact that there wasn't even an ATTEMPT throughout the show to explain what happened. Then again, Cal was clearly on her way out, no...
Forum: Older Series 2009-09-19, 17:48
Replies: 2,739
Views: 495,393
Posted By Mentar
They were showing the parallel between Mio's...

They were showing the parallel between Mio's father (the underworld kumicho that Shiga bowed to last episode) and Reiji. Both are captured in the violent and cruel underworld, and they can not...
Forum: Older Series 2009-09-19, 15:02
Replies: 2,739
Views: 495,393
Posted By Mentar
Buy the game and play the Cal path. Seriously. 20...

Buy the game and play the Cal path. Seriously. 20 bucks aren't too much for this gem.
Forum: Older Series 2009-09-19, 14:42
Replies: 2,739
Views: 495,393
Posted By Mentar
Actually, you might want to rewatch the ep with...

Actually, you might want to rewatch the ep with subs, you show a few misunderstandings.



Actually, it was Reiji who challenged Cal to a duel, and Reiji himself blames him for Cal's death....
Forum: Older Series 2009-09-19, 13:59
Replies: 2,739
Views: 495,393
Posted By Mentar
Well, subs out. Some remarks from me. As a...

Well, subs out. Some remarks from me.

As a declared Cal-shipper, I'd still give the episode a 10, now that all details were fleshed out with the script. They added a few things and removed a few...
Forum: Older Series 2009-09-17, 17:05
Replies: 2,739
Views: 495,393
Posted By Mentar
For those who feel disappointed now... I can...

For those who feel disappointed now...

I can say this much, they handled the scene exceptionally well. It certainly beats any watered-down harem ending by a mile. If Phantom had the usual episodic...
Showing results 1 to 25 of 152
Page 1 of 7 1 23 Last »

 
Forum Jump

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 18:16.

Contact Us - Support - AnimeSuki.com - Archive - Top

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
We use Silk.