AnimeSuki Forums

Register Forum Rules FAQ Members List Social Groups Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read

Go Back   AnimeSuki Forum > Search Forums

Notices

Showing results 1 to 25 of 97
Search took 0.01 seconds.
Search: Posts Made By: Arkwright
Forum: Umineko 2010-12-30, 04:59
Replies: 3,726
Views: 385,486
Posted By Arkwright
For Kylon99, I'm speaking specifically regarding...

For Kylon99, I'm speaking specifically regarding AuraTwilight's theory, not really general questions. Basically I'm just asking for clarification on how that particular theory answers these...
Forum: Umineko 2010-12-30, 04:07
Replies: 3,726
Views: 385,486
Posted By Arkwright
So the parents in the dining room discuss the...

So the parents in the dining room discuss the plan to fake the twilights. Natsuhi leaves early. Jessica gives her the charm in secret, which Maria had given to Jessica. It shouldn't have been part of...
Forum: Umineko 2010-12-30, 03:13
Replies: 3,726
Views: 385,486
Posted By Arkwright
She doesn't tell Wright that she saw any of the...

She doesn't tell Wright that she saw any of the imaginary witch friends. Will can probably confirm that she saw Shannon there with Beatrice if he wants to. It ignores those parent-ish hints. It...
Forum: Umineko 2010-12-30, 02:22
Replies: 3,726
Views: 385,486
Posted By Arkwright
I remember what's being referred to. This is...

I remember what's being referred to. This is while Will was theatergoing with Maria. Rosa and Maria are on an off-season visit to Rokkenjima. Rosa says she's going off to talk to Krauss, and Maria...
Forum: Umineko 2010-01-07, 15:18
Replies: 35,366
Views: 2,934,260
Posted By Arkwright
Didn't he say he had seen it already? Or do you...

Didn't he say he had seen it already? Or do you mean that he played along and inspected it later?

Also when he sees the magic circle on the shed, he mentions having seen a similar "scribble" on...
Forum: Umineko 2010-01-06, 14:30
Replies: 3,413
Views: 418,112
Posted By Arkwright
Kumasawa could know about the occult and the love...

Kumasawa could know about the occult and the love stories, have access to the money, and is female, which were your four criteria. That's why I said the first part.

The second part indicates that...
Forum: Umineko 2010-01-06, 11:39
Replies: 35,366
Views: 2,934,260
Posted By Arkwright
2. Can't check at the moment, but I seem to...

2. Can't check at the moment, but I seem to remember that when Genji saw the circle on the shed, he remembered something on Natsuhi's door that he described as a drawing, not as just random markings....
Forum: Umineko 2010-01-06, 08:21
Replies: 35,366
Views: 2,934,260
Posted By Arkwright
If we assume the witch is not real, episode 4...

If we assume the witch is not real, episode 4 strongly suggests that the witch killings were supposed to be fake, but something went wrong. It's not too much of a stretch to imagine that other...
Forum: Umineko 2010-01-06, 08:11
Replies: 35,366
Views: 2,934,260
Posted By Arkwright
Well, this is probably the most useful way to...

Well, this is probably the most useful way to respond. Things that are still unexplained:

-"Golden butterflies" in the hallway. Red herring of being attacked by the culprit?
-The magic circle on...
Forum: Umineko 2010-01-06, 07:32
Replies: 3,413
Views: 418,112
Posted By Arkwright
A few things in here to respond to, I guess I'll...

A few things in here to respond to, I guess I'll work backwards...



Remember the method with which Erika "searched the whole island." First, Erika determined that Kinzo could not have left the...
Forum: Umineko 2010-01-05, 18:26
Replies: 35,366
Views: 2,934,260
Posted By Arkwright
The voice and mannerisms are the biggest issues I...

The voice and mannerisms are the biggest issues I have with the idea, personally (as... disturbingly fitting as a morbid parody of Detective Conan might be.) Nevertheless, putting that aside...

I...
Forum: Umineko 2010-01-05, 16:06
Replies: 35,366
Views: 2,934,260
Posted By Arkwright
I've said my thoughts on the general Shannon =...

I've said my thoughts on the general Shannon = Kanon = killer theory. The red in episode 3 can even be avoided with no problems if you assume a Person X was the Shannon who died, but that's not what...
Forum: Umineko 2010-01-05, 14:47
Replies: 35,366
Views: 2,934,260
Posted By Arkwright
I would say that a theory which refuses to answer...

I would say that a theory which refuses to answer the two questions regarding Asumu and Battler holds no love for the writer.

I've already said that "assuming things that aren't specified...
Forum: Umineko 2010-01-05, 10:50
Replies: 35,366
Views: 2,934,260
Posted By Arkwright
It is certainly an assumption to say for sure...

It is certainly an assumption to say for sure that the Knox rules don't apply to earlier episodes, but it is also an assumption to say that they do. Apparently even Virgilia and Dlanor didn't know...
Forum: Umineko 2010-01-05, 09:29
Replies: 35,366
Views: 2,934,260
Posted By Arkwright
This is actually the premise I started with for...

This is actually the premise I started with for my theory regarding the first four games.

It explains why the murders continue despite the epitaph being solved - Beatrice never planned to kill...
Forum: Umineko 2010-01-04, 19:11
Replies: 35,366
Views: 2,934,260
Posted By Arkwright
I know this was said before, but let's not use...

I know this was said before, but let's not use the characters' appearance as hints. I could say that Battler's hair color could mean that both he and Ange have the same mother (Kyrie), but I wouldn't...
Forum: Umineko 2010-01-04, 13:59
Replies: 35,366
Views: 2,934,260
Posted By Arkwright
Copy-pasting: The second twilight was...

Copy-pasting:



The second twilight was planned to be fake from the start. Genji drew the magic circle on the door while Kumasawa and Kanon went to get the wire cutter. There was no problem with...
Forum: Umineko 2010-01-04, 13:33
Replies: 35,366
Views: 2,934,260
Posted By Arkwright
I think the operative theory would be that the...

I think the operative theory would be that the "baby from 19 years ago" would actually be the "baby from 18 years ago"... It's easier to imagine how they could misconstrue the date on that...
Forum: Umineko 2010-01-04, 00:08
Replies: 35,366
Views: 2,934,260
Posted By Arkwright
I can't say I really follow... If she had said "A...

I can't say I really follow... If she had said "A world where only my magic can possibly exist!" then I would agree with you, but saying "A world where magic that isn't mine cannot possibly exist!"...
Forum: Umineko 2010-01-03, 18:19
Replies: 35,366
Views: 2,934,260
Posted By Arkwright
Well, the "multiple personalities" concept is not...

Well, the "multiple personalities" concept is not one that I personally endorse, it was just part of the "Battler is already dead" concept. I know I have seen a fair amount of it in Jessica theories,...
Forum: Umineko 2010-01-03, 17:35
Replies: 35,366
Views: 2,934,260
Posted By Arkwright
I don't see any problems with these. If we...

I don't see any problems with these.

If we assume that magic does not exist at all even outside the game board - for example, saying that Battler is in Purgatory, or that Battler is playing a...
Forum: Umineko 2010-01-03, 14:26
Replies: 35,366
Views: 2,934,260
Posted By Arkwright
I have no problems with trying to work it out....

I have no problems with trying to work it out. Actually, originally I liked the Shannon = Kanon theory. But when I realized that the Ep3 first twilight red truth seemed to shut out the possibility, I...
Forum: Umineko 2010-01-03, 03:01
Replies: 35,366
Views: 2,934,260
Posted By Arkwright
By the same reasoning, we already know from other...

By the same reasoning, we already know from other information that Kinzo is already dead, so it should be unnecessary to provide a new hint. But despite that (or perhaps because of that) it is still...
Forum: Umineko 2010-01-03, 00:35
Replies: 35,366
Views: 2,934,260
Posted By Arkwright
But there was a time when "Shannon" and "Kanon"...

But there was a time when "Shannon" and "Kanon" were in different rooms. In that case, what is the significance of Shannon not appearing until Erika came in the door? Besides, both pieces were under...
Forum: Umineko 2010-01-02, 22:09
Replies: 35,366
Views: 2,934,260
Posted By Arkwright
Before I forget, what was it in the beginning of...

Before I forget, what was it in the beginning of episode 2 that couldn't be fully explained without Shannon = Kanon?



She didn't really need to be looking for them, she just had to see the...
Showing results 1 to 25 of 97

 
Forum Jump

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:05.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2015, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
We use Silk.