AnimeSuki Forums

Register Forum Rules FAQ Members List Social Groups Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read

Go Back   AnimeSuki Forum > Search Forums

Notices

Showing results 1 to 25 of 59
Search took 0.01 seconds.
Search: Posts Made By: Valentine
Forum: Umineko 2009-06-28, 07:24
Replies: 4,591
Views: 422,605
Posted By Valentine
I've no problems with this part. I don't really...

I've no problems with this part. I don't really think there was nothing in the other boxes, and it wouldn't be surprising if there were another one or two boxes being used for the same thing for...
Forum: Umineko 2009-06-27, 16:03
Replies: 4,591
Views: 422,605
Posted By Valentine
Got to say I'm seeing it the other way around, at...

Got to say I'm seeing it the other way around, at least as regards the extra safe deposit boxes. All we actually know about the twenty safe deposit boxes is that they belong to the same account....
Forum: Umineko 2009-06-27, 11:30
Replies: 4,591
Views: 422,605
Posted By Valentine
I was talking about whether or not she really...

I was talking about whether or not she really believed Battler wasn't Kinzo's grandson when she was getting him to repeat the lines about Asumu. Battler not knowing what she was talking about with...
Forum: Umineko 2009-06-27, 10:05
Replies: 4,591
Views: 422,605
Posted By Valentine
Technically, we've only seen proof of 100 million...

Technically, we've only seen proof of 100 million present and 3 safe deposit boxes used for paying relatives of the deceased. Just because someone has an account with twenty safe deposit boxes...
Forum: Umineko 2009-06-26, 15:00
Replies: 4,591
Views: 422,605
Posted By Valentine
I didn't say he said that, I said that he wasn't...

I didn't say he said that, I said that he wasn't unable to say it, because he didn't try to say it. A small difference, but an important one. Beatrice directed what he was to repeat in such a way...
Forum: Umineko 2009-06-26, 08:06
Replies: 4,591
Views: 422,605
Posted By Valentine
The thing he tried and failed to say was "I was...

The thing he tried and failed to say was "I was born from Ushiromiya Asumu" though, which can't really be interpreted metaphorically. He was never specifically unable to say "I am Ushiromiya Asumu's...
Forum: Umineko 2009-06-26, 06:37
Replies: 4,591
Views: 422,605
Posted By Valentine
I don't think traps were actually denied for...

I don't think traps were actually denied for episode 1 Kanon either, though Lambda made fun of Battler trying to explain practically everything else with traps. While it's possible though, I kind of...
Forum: Umineko 2009-06-23, 06:05
Replies: 4,591
Views: 422,605
Posted By Valentine
You missed a couple of confirmed ones. Kanon was...

You missed a couple of confirmed ones. Kanon was confirmed dead in episode 2. Eva and Hideyoshi at the second twilight of episode 1, and all six at the first twilight of episode 2 were confirmed as...
Forum: Umineko 2009-06-22, 04:09
Replies: 4,591
Views: 422,605
Posted By Valentine
She said that they couldn't have mistaken anyone...

She said that they couldn't have mistaken anyone else for Kanon. She didn't specifically say that they saw him though, so there's nothing contradicting them just lying about having seen Kanon at all.
Forum: Umineko 2009-06-21, 07:37
Replies: 4,591
Views: 422,605
Posted By Valentine
I'm pretty sure Rosa was responsible for the...

I'm pretty sure Rosa was responsible for the first and second twilights, but there is still an out for Rosa for the Natsuhi's room murders. It's never said in red that the people from the fourth...
Forum: Umineko 2009-06-19, 15:13
Replies: 4,591
Views: 422,605
Posted By Valentine
There's red text that she opened it in the...

There's red text that she opened it in the morning, and thereby got the key though, isn't there? Most likely, she couldn't be sure that nobody would be with her when she was opening the envelope, or...
Forum: Umineko 2009-06-19, 06:08
Replies: 4,591
Views: 422,605
Posted By Valentine
I don't think so. From the time it was received,...

I don't think so. From the time it was received, it couldn't be unsealed until the next day, and it didn't pass through anyone else's hands until it was unsealed, so whenever she received it, Maria...
Forum: Umineko 2009-06-18, 16:06
Replies: 4,591
Views: 422,605
Posted By Valentine
Something you're missing there. It wasn't stated...

Something you're missing there. It wasn't stated that when Rosa opened the envelope in the morning to get the key that it was the first time she'd opened it. If she opened it after midnight, used it...
Forum: Umineko 2009-06-18, 12:28
Replies: 4,591
Views: 422,605
Posted By Valentine
Delivering the letter to Maria after the first...

Delivering the letter to Maria after the first twilight would mean sneaking in to the cousins' room and having a discussion with Maria without waking any of them though, and that Maria was actively...
Forum: Umineko 2009-06-18, 07:15
Replies: 4,591
Views: 422,605
Posted By Valentine
Actually, I was kind of wondering if the red text...

Actually, I was kind of wondering if the red text could be used differently by different people to some extent. Obviously something objectively true such as "You (Ushiromiya Battler) were not born...
Forum: Umineko 2009-06-17, 06:20
Replies: 4,591
Views: 422,605
Posted By Valentine
Ah, that is a problem. Time to read it again, I...

Ah, that is a problem. Time to read it again, I guess.
Forum: Umineko 2009-06-17, 06:14
Replies: 4,591
Views: 422,605
Posted By Valentine
I don't really get what you mean by it being...

I don't really get what you mean by it being cheap. There have been plenty of hints that Beatrice doesn't consider furniture to be human, so it's not exactly coming out of nowhere, and we can count...
Forum: Umineko 2009-06-17, 05:55
Replies: 4,591
Views: 422,605
Posted By Valentine
Can Battler abuse the red text to discover the...

Can Battler abuse the red text to discover the answer to anything Beatrice refuses to repeat in red now that he can use it as well?

For instance, in the second twilight of episode 2, Battler tried...
Forum: Umineko 2009-06-05, 09:15
Replies: 1,941
Views: 261,163
Posted By Valentine
Compare who's alive between the different...

Compare who's alive between the different episodes, and their situations. Episode 3 is the first time Krauss, Rudolph or Kyrie weren't part of the first twilight. I'd put those three plus Eva as the...
Forum: Umineko 2009-05-31, 08:45
Replies: 1,941
Views: 261,163
Posted By Valentine
Or George, who didn't get red text for his death...

Or George, who didn't get red text for his death until later either. I think he kind of fits better with what happens later as well. If George was for some reason convinced Nanjo was responsible for...
Forum: Umineko 2009-05-28, 09:17
Replies: 550
Views: 121,422
Posted By Valentine
"If they didn't think of it, it can't be the...

"If they didn't think of it, it can't be the case"? What kind of logic is that? If they'd come up with the answer to how it was done in the story it wouldn't be a mystery and we wouldn't be trying to...
Forum: Umineko 2009-05-28, 07:20
Replies: 550
Views: 121,422
Posted By Valentine
The bit you're thinking of is "No device could...

The bit you're thinking of is "No device could have the effect of locking the door from the outside without using a key." This method of locking the door from the outside uses the key though - it...
Forum: Umineko 2009-05-28, 06:07
Replies: 550
Views: 121,422
Posted By Valentine
There's a loophole in the red text that'd let a...

There's a loophole in the red text that'd let a murderer without one of the servant's master keys lock the door. Beatrice claims that "When locked, entry is not possible by any means." There's no...
Forum: Umineko 2009-05-27, 14:40
Replies: 550
Views: 121,422
Posted By Valentine
That's only true if you assume that the person...

That's only true if you assume that the person who gave Maria the key and the killer are the same person. Human Beatrice could have given her the key and Rosa could have been the one who used it to...
Forum: Umineko 2009-05-25, 14:14
Replies: 524
Views: 161,814
Posted By Valentine
It doesn't help to get around the killer having...

It doesn't help to get around the killer having to still be hiding in their room, but the murder doesn't have to have taken place in their room. Eva and Hideyoshi could have been killed walking back...
Showing results 1 to 25 of 59

 
Forum Jump

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 19:05.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2015, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
We use Silk.