AnimeSuki Forums

Register Forum Rules FAQ Members List Social Groups Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read

Go Back   AnimeSuki Forum > Search Forums

Notices

Showing results 1 to 25 of 496
Search took 0.01 seconds.
Search: Posts Made By: Smeckledorf
Forum: Umineko 2012-07-03, 18:06
Replies: 34,522
Views: 2,524,169
Posted By Smeckledorf
Well, it was to give Battler more hope. No matter...

Well, it was to give Battler more hope. No matter which way you look at it, the game was a losing game for Beatrice. The longer the game went on, the more red truths she gave out, and the more...
Forum: Umineko 2012-04-17, 21:05
Replies: 34,522
Views: 2,524,169
Posted By Smeckledorf
He does some pretty nice deductions, his own...

He does some pretty nice deductions, his own theory is not by any means bad. However, his denial and so-called proof for Shkanon is downright nonsensical.
Most specifically, how he thought Kanon...
Forum: Umineko 2012-01-01, 05:12
Replies: 34,522
Views: 2,524,169
Posted By Smeckledorf
Interesting stuff. By work in progress do you...

Interesting stuff. By work in progress do you mean there is more to it that you haven't translated or do you mean that you have to clean it up? If that's all, I can't say I am shocked but he went a...
Forum: Umineko 2011-12-26, 02:37
Replies: 1,772
Views: 314,266
Posted By Smeckledorf
Yea, I remember now that Beatrice 2 looked...

Yea, I remember now that Beatrice 2 looked nothing like Beatrice... oh wait...
How much does one's opinion on likelihood matter when it comes to solutions? Not much. Are we really only going by the...
Forum: Umineko 2011-12-26, 02:28
Replies: 34,522
Views: 2,524,169
Posted By Smeckledorf
Aside from claiming it to be rule Z, that last...

Aside from claiming it to be rule Z, that last part has been known for a while. Beatrice only started the game, she probably did not even directly cause any deaths. She, her self, has said she is...
Forum: Umineko 2011-12-25, 05:49
Replies: 1,772
Views: 314,266
Posted By Smeckledorf
Beatrice 2 looked exactly like Beatrice 1....

Beatrice 2 looked exactly like Beatrice 1. Battler looks like Kinzo. I was toying with the notion that that Ikuko is the daughter or Battler and Ikuko.
I know Ikuko speaks as if she was the Ikuko...
Forum: Umineko 2011-12-25, 05:39
Replies: 34,522
Views: 2,524,169
Posted By Smeckledorf
My one problem with Author theory was that no one...

My one problem with Author theory was that no one on the island survived. Without a survivor the credibility goes to 0. Ange meeting Battler had to be true.

Anyway, about the whole rules thing....
Forum: Umineko 2011-12-22, 17:40
Replies: 1,772
Views: 314,266
Posted By Smeckledorf
I have nothing against you for liking the...

I have nothing against you for liking the episode. I don't know why anyone would. My beef is with R07. An answer is owed to mystery.

I also believe Kyrie/Rudolph to be murderers, but there are...
Forum: Umineko 2011-12-22, 17:32
Replies: 34,522
Views: 2,524,169
Posted By Smeckledorf
Frankly, I am with Jan-Poo, here. I have thought...

Frankly, I am with Jan-Poo, here. I have thought about the mystery to the extent I possibly could. I could argue theories all day, but to no avail. We need an answer to substantiate our theories. As...
Forum: Umineko 2011-12-20, 18:09
Replies: 1,772
Views: 314,266
Posted By Smeckledorf
He did give that to us twice, and it seems...

He did give that to us twice, and it seems viable. Read some of SSVD's novels and see how close 'viable' gets you to the truth. We were never promised a truth, I cannot deny that. However, he did say...
Forum: Umineko 2011-12-20, 16:46
Replies: 1,772
Views: 314,266
Posted By Smeckledorf
If it wasn't a mystery then he trolled people on...

If it wasn't a mystery then he trolled people on as if it were one. He has been quoted saying a solution is possible, more than once. The fact of the matter is, he had a choice with this episode. End...
Forum: Umineko 2011-12-20, 05:21
Replies: 1,772
Views: 314,266
Posted By Smeckledorf
Of course, he would not want people to abandon...

Of course, he would not want people to abandon his works completely. However, what is the point of theorizing on a permanently closed catbox? His decision to dodge questions is what discourages...
Forum: Umineko 2011-12-19, 18:26
Replies: 1,772
Views: 314,266
Posted By Smeckledorf
A world can mean a lot of things. It could just...

A world can mean a lot of things. It could just mean Rokkenjima is inside of a catbox and we will never know what happen and Battler chooses to interpret a reality where Beatrice is not a killer. I...
Forum: Umineko 2011-12-19, 16:51
Replies: 1,772
Views: 314,266
Posted By Smeckledorf
I actually did not like episode 8. It did not...

I actually did not like episode 8. It did not give me the one thing I wanted, you don't have to guess what that is. Anyway, that is an interesting literal interpretation. Battler is lost with...
Forum: Umineko 2011-12-19, 16:21
Replies: 1,772
Views: 314,266
Posted By Smeckledorf
She did make a pretty big deal of abandoning her...

She did make a pretty big deal of abandoning her name. At the same time, I see that she kept some parts of Ange.
Forum: Umineko 2010-12-13, 01:43
Replies: 34,522
Views: 2,524,169
Posted By Smeckledorf
I have to agree yet disagree with Erika being...

I have to agree yet disagree with Erika being Yasu. I agree that it fits from the angle of a persona of Yasu; however, I don't think Yasu is a murderer. Erika seems to be a murderer, so she seems to...
Forum: Umineko 2010-12-11, 22:38
Replies: 34,522
Views: 2,524,169
Posted By Smeckledorf
I still don't know if Yasu is the child from 19...

I still don't know if Yasu is the child from 19 years ago. Even if Kinzo was sorry for what he had did and cried every day, I still don't think Genji would have showed Kinzo who the child was. I...
Forum: Umineko 2010-11-24, 00:23
Replies: 3,726
Views: 356,105
Posted By Smeckledorf
Well, seeing as Shanon and Kanon are her, you...

Well, seeing as Shanon and Kanon are her, you could say that they were based off of Yasu.
Forum: Umineko 2010-11-23, 20:11
Replies: 3,726
Views: 356,105
Posted By Smeckledorf
Probably not, but at the very least she made...

Probably not, but at the very least she made people look dead.
Forum: Umineko 2010-11-22, 22:09
Replies: 34,522
Views: 2,524,169
Posted By Smeckledorf
He shot himself!!! jk

He shot himself!!! jk
Forum: Umineko 2010-11-22, 17:55
Replies: 34,522
Views: 2,524,169
Posted By Smeckledorf
Better than just a miracle miss, twice? I don't...

Better than just a miracle miss, twice? I don't know...
There are many scenarios one could come up with that could make a better truth than what we saw. Bernkastel didn't want to be right, I think...
Forum: Umineko 2010-11-22, 17:46
Replies: 34,522
Views: 2,524,169
Posted By Smeckledorf
Martial artists themselves admit guns beat...

Martial artists themselves admit guns beat martial arts.
Forum: Umineko 2010-11-22, 17:10
Replies: 34,522
Views: 2,524,169
Posted By Smeckledorf
I don't know about Yasu having a misplaced heart,...

I don't know about Yasu having a misplaced heart, that gunshot would have still probably hit it and the blood loss would still be unbearable even if it missed his/her heart. All s/he could have done,...
Forum: Umineko 2010-11-03, 19:12
Replies: 34,522
Views: 2,524,169
Posted By Smeckledorf
You say it is a FACT that Battler did not meet...

You say it is a FACT that Battler did not meet the qualifications. Go ahead, present the facts.


It is very true that the child from 19 years ago would have a distinct disadvantage in solving...
Forum: Umineko 2010-11-03, 01:38
Replies: 34,522
Views: 2,524,169
Posted By Smeckledorf
Fairly certain that Kinzo believed the person who...

Fairly certain that Kinzo believed the person who would solve the epitaph was the child from 19 years ago. Also, the child from 19 years ago WOULD have a blood connection to Beatrice, so if Battler...
Showing results 1 to 25 of 496

 
Forum Jump

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:10.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
We use Silk.