AnimeSuki Forums

Register Forum Rules FAQ Members List Social Groups Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read

Go Back   AnimeSuki Forum > Search Forums

Notices

Showing results 1 to 21 of 21
Search took 0.01 seconds.
Search: Posts Made By: Zork
Forum: Umineko 2013-05-02, 12:36
Replies: 794
Views: 85,238
Posted By Zork
Thanks, that text dump helps a lot. The...

Thanks, that text dump helps a lot.

The events following dinner are much more chaotic so it's taking me quite some time to make sense of them. Just a couple points this time:Nanjo is upstairs in...
Forum: Umineko 2013-05-01, 12:55
Replies: 794
Views: 85,238
Posted By Zork
Guess it's time to start taking shots before the...

Guess it's time to start taking shots before the tea party.

This could be embarrassingly wrong (or old news - I haven't really kept up well on what others have theorized), but the text dump won't...
Forum: Umineko 2013-03-10, 20:57
Replies: 794
Views: 85,238
Posted By Zork
So, I've been reading Redaction for a little...

So, I've been reading Redaction for a little while now and I though I should at the very least post to thank and encourage Renall since I'm enjoying his work a fair bit.

That said, it seems like...
Forum: Umineko 2011-12-25, 15:10
Replies: 34,543
Views: 2,565,187
Posted By Zork
Well, if he's a "plagiarist hack" then it's not...

Well, if he's a "plagiarist hack" then it's not because he wrote a no-culprit ending; he would have been one from the very beginning. The scenario on Rokkenjima uses an awful lot of elements from...
Forum: Umineko 2011-12-23, 05:56
Replies: 34,543
Views: 2,565,187
Posted By Zork
All the talk about rules X, Y, and Z sent me to...

All the talk about rules X, Y, and Z sent me to go look at the TIPS again, and it may finally have helped me. Here's hoping this is the last stab I take at Umineko...

The explosion. No argument...
Forum: Umineko 2011-11-11, 11:11
Replies: 3,726
Views: 359,600
Posted By Zork
It seems pretty clear that Bernkastel got Lion...

It seems pretty clear that Bernkastel got Lion into the game by including the possibility that the baby from eighteen years ago didn't fall off a cliff (and thus, Lion). Presumably that makes this...
Forum: Umineko 2010-08-21, 03:19
Replies: 5,320
Views: 531,030
Posted By Zork
Well, Krauss, Rudolf, Hideyoshi, and Gohda...were...

Well, Krauss, Rudolf, Hideyoshi, and Gohda...were not involved in the murders of Natsuhi, Eva, Kyrie, Rosa, Maria, and Battler. However, if your only immediate concern is satisfying red truths then...
Forum: Umineko 2010-08-20, 19:07
Replies: 5,320
Views: 531,030
Posted By Zork
Boring? Yes. I absolutely agree that would be an...

Boring? Yes. I absolutely agree that would be an anticlimactic scene. I'm pretty sure that dramatic imperative isn't a valid basis for a logical argument, though.

The issue of Knox's second is a...
Forum: Umineko 2010-08-20, 15:19
Replies: 5,320
Views: 531,030
Posted By Zork
Alright, let me try a different question. Why...

Alright, let me try a different question. Why doesn't Battler just try saying "there is no logic error?" If the red is always the absolute truth, this should be a satisfactory solution.
Forum: Umineko 2010-08-19, 21:48
Replies: 5,320
Views: 531,030
Posted By Zork
My impression was that when Battler was in the...

My impression was that when Battler was in the logic error, his one and only task was to prove that a scenario existed where all the red text is satisfied. Presumably, this would satisfy this issue...
Forum: Umineko 2010-08-19, 05:20
Replies: 5,320
Views: 531,030
Posted By Zork
I have one problem with the idea that it's...

I have one problem with the idea that it's utterly impossible to state something false in red. If that's the case, how could you ever construct a logic error? If a red statement would create a...
Forum: Umineko 2010-08-17, 14:28
Replies: 5,320
Views: 531,030
Posted By Zork
ShKanon isn't actually necessary for this...

ShKanon isn't actually necessary for this specific trick. Kanon is a pseudonym for a servant of the Ushiromiya family - so-called furniture. What happens if he quits his job? If ShKanon can...
Forum: Umineko 2010-07-21, 11:28
Replies: 5,320
Views: 531,030
Posted By Zork
Battler does talk about that murder in EP6: ...

Battler does talk about that murder in EP6:

http://img7.imageshack.us/img7/4775/uminekoeveryone2.png (http://img7.imageshack.us/i/uminekoeveryone2.png/)

Unfortunately, his explanation is far...
Forum: Umineko 2010-01-31, 05:25
Replies: 3,413
Views: 390,622
Posted By Zork
This is a few pages back, but I wanted to address...

This is a few pages back, but I wanted to address it. Sorry that it's a bit off-topic from the current discussion.



For what it's worth, I actually have one:

There's a bunch of red text...
Forum: Umineko 2010-01-18, 16:42
Replies: 3,413
Views: 390,622
Posted By Zork
I think a step back to look at the big picture...

I think a step back to look at the big picture may be warranted. Sure, Erika presented lots of clues in the trial that hadn't really been presented to the readers beforehand. Why is this so...
Forum: Umineko 2010-01-15, 12:16
Replies: 3,413
Views: 390,622
Posted By Zork
I vaguely recall someone in EP 5 stating that...

I vaguely recall someone in EP 5 stating that Lambda wanted to sway Battler over to the witch's side. It makes some sense from a strategic standpoint; while Battler is earnestly playing the witch...
Forum: Umineko 2010-01-09, 13:26
Replies: 3,413
Views: 390,622
Posted By Zork
Well, the date of that particular scene is not...

Well, the date of that particular scene is not made entirely clear. It could have been any time between October 1984 (the preceding scene) and December 1985 (the smashing of the mirror). According to...
Forum: Umineko 2010-01-09, 08:45
Replies: 3,413
Views: 390,622
Posted By Zork
Actually, I am somewhat suspicious about George...

Actually, I am somewhat suspicious about George and Shannon. I don't ever recall Shannon expressing any feelings for George in Battler's presence. He always seems to learn about the relationship from...
Forum: Umineko 2010-01-06, 16:51
Replies: 3,413
Views: 390,622
Posted By Zork
There were a few points where I wasn't able to...

There were a few points where I wasn't able to follow your train of reasoning:

Why assert that the murderer sent the bank cards? I don't see a point in the murderer doing it. Not that the M.O....
Forum: Umineko 2010-01-06, 15:13
Replies: 506
Views: 96,688
Posted By Zork
Like I said, I was pretty sure it wasn't the...

Like I said, I was pretty sure it wasn't the right way to go but I just had to point it out because it's amusing.

Kishin: It's 里 which is used for village elsewhere in the epitaph, and also the...
Forum: Umineko 2010-01-04, 21:20
Replies: 506
Views: 96,688
Posted By Zork
So, I doubt I'm on the real trail here, but the...

So, I doubt I'm on the real trail here, but the coincidences I came across were too amusing not to share.

The visual novels mentioned that Maria's name is possibly involved with the epitaph, so...
Showing results 1 to 21 of 21

 
Forum Jump

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 13:49.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
We use Silk.