Forum: Umineko
2014-03-06, 04:40
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,746,993
There has been a lot of talk about Yasu and...
There has been a lot of talk about Yasu and morality of her "actions".
I somewhat agree with Renall, somewhat disagree.
I agree that her actions were poorly explained, but actually think that...
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2014-02-04, 13:02
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,746,993
But even though I don't myself believe in Rosa...
But even though I don't myself believe in Rosa being a culprit in any way, the ides of her solving epitah is sort of interesting detail: it is clearly shown that she CAN solve it, and for example in...
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2014-02-03, 15:09
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,746,993
If I had to say, probably because the entire...
If I had to say, probably because the entire theory was always on an "interesting theory" stage. One of the reasons is also that it is somewhat clearly stated what characters are "canonically" part...
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2014-02-03, 14:41
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,746,993
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2014-02-03, 12:55
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,746,993
I believe the 3rd layer/story mentioned in our...
I believe the 3rd layer/story mentioned in our confessions is the take that Yasu wasn't a violent killer but a suffering angsty girl. Our confessions, and pretty much every board, is written into...
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2014-01-26, 02:42
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,746,993
Wow, thanks for the quick reply.
That's it,...
Wow, thanks for the quick reply.
That's it, I guess? I feel somehow empty, even though I believed that is somewhat what happened during the prime. At least it is in my opinion the truth that made...
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2014-01-25, 13:01
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,746,993
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2013-11-11, 14:58
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,746,993
Don't know if anyone has pointed this out, but...
Don't know if anyone has pointed this out, but there is a quite of talk in ep 4 about ange being left out of mariage sorciere and everyone in the club being very pissed at her. Maybe ange isn't in...
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2013-11-10, 11:11
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,746,993
I always thought the ending with Beatrice and...
I always thought the ending with Beatrice and Battler in the boat was a hint towards there was some kind of boat accident. I personally believe the theory that Yasu died in the accident, or that she...
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2013-09-29, 05:30
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,746,993
Hell, maybe they didn't even believe in any...
Hell, maybe they didn't even believe in any goddamn bomb and the switch. I believe this was discussed somewhere before, as the bombs exists somewhere hidden, Yasu has no evidence of bomb threat being...
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2013-08-25, 14:57
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,746,993
Now I don't know if I clearly understood your...
Now I don't know if I clearly understood your point here, but if you are using that video to argue that guns are not loud as hell, your argument is bit on the sloppy side. Even the guy in the video...
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2013-08-24, 19:39
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,746,993
Returning to the topic of guns, has anyone ever...
Returning to the topic of guns, has anyone ever addressed the issue of actual sound of a gunshot?
The scale of the island (like between mansion and guesthouse) hasn't been properly addressed iirc,...
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2013-08-24, 16:53
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,746,993
I don't know, I really don't... If we take it...
I don't know, I really don't... If we take it that Yasu is Shkannontrice then the culprit is actually mentioned, but the trick only is crossdressing. Therefore "Yasu" is not a new, unmentioned...
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2013-08-24, 15:13
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,746,993
First of all we should consider if Ryu has any...
First of all we should consider if Ryu has any kind of knowledge in guns. If OC said that Yasu also has a pistol, okay, but I can easily see different kind of wounds explained by Ryu simply not...
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2013-08-11, 06:09
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,746,993
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2013-08-10, 17:11
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,746,993
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2013-08-03, 17:51
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,746,993
Though was it directly said that way? I really...
Though was it directly said that way? I really don't remember. If it were, that pretty much destroys my theory.
Only thing I specifically remember was thinking that shooting a hanged person is a...
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2013-08-03, 17:37
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,746,993
I don't remember the exact red truths but...
I don't remember the exact red truths but wouldn't it be possible if Yasu pointed them from the window with a gun and threatened them to tie a noose around their heads? After placing the head on the...
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2013-07-27, 18:31
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,746,993
Lately there has been some discussion about...
Lately there has been some discussion about umineko manga
I'm especially curious how they have "fixed" the episode 8 to a form it was supposed to be before rushed release. In what sense have...
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2013-07-26, 18:30
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,746,993
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2013-07-26, 14:52
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,746,993
I don't think red truth should be even used in...
I don't think red truth should be even used in discussion if it isn't a direct citation from the game. I like how many people have been using it previously for some things that are totally opinion...
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2013-07-22, 06:08
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,746,993
Though we can explain her silence with very...
Though we can explain her silence with very simple logic
Eva never told the truth because it was harmful directly towards herself: she was somehow involved in the killings thus making her partly...
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2013-07-21, 19:05
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,746,993
Though Shannon and Kanon always talk about...
Though Shannon and Kanon always talk about everyone being resurrected when reaching the golden land. This could be easily seen as a hint of Yasu not being the culprit and not intending to kill...
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2013-07-07, 13:29
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,746,993
I like how there are certain persons who were...
I like how there are certain persons who were basically never expected to be the culprit. Even though Nanjo as doctor gets suspected of being accomplice, people like he and Gohda are not considered...
|
|
Forum: Umineko
2013-06-23, 08:56
|
|
Replies: 35,614
Views: 5,746,993
|
