AnimeSuki Forums

Register Forum Rules FAQ Members List Social Groups Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read

Go Back   AnimeSuki Forum > Search Forums

Notices

Showing results 1 to 25 of 26
Search took 0.01 seconds.
Search: Posts Made By: Saorin
Forum: Umineko 2013-01-09, 13:27
Replies: 34,566
Views: 2,597,121
Posted By Saorin
Hey everyone, it's been quite a while since I...

Hey everyone, it's been quite a while since I last dropped by...Phew. Seems some people have been staying active. Pretty amazing, considering the time...

I've just started reading the manga, now...
Forum: Umineko 2012-05-15, 09:29
Replies: 34,566
Views: 2,597,121
Posted By Saorin
If we talk about a "realistical" approach to...

If we talk about a "realistical" approach to love, I think Umineko kinda missed it in my view. I won't talk about how you shouldn't misinterprete funny remarks like "I'll come and get you a white...
Forum: Umineko 2012-05-15, 05:12
Replies: 34,566
Views: 2,597,121
Posted By Saorin
Haha I don't actually see through that. But I do...

Haha I don't actually see through that. But I do think it's striking that WITHIN the forgeries there are hints pointing to a 2nd culprit - the one being rather brutal without any references to the...
Forum: Umineko 2012-05-15, 05:00
Replies: 34,566
Views: 2,597,121
Posted By Saorin
I think that letter would actually make sense if...

I think that letter would actually make sense if we assume it was only supposed to be a murder mystery. The victims wouldn't really have been dead and they could have "revived" when the epitaph was...
Forum: Umineko 2012-05-15, 04:46
Replies: 34,566
Views: 2,597,121
Posted By Saorin
After having pondered the topic a bit more, I...

After having pondered the topic a bit more, I guess I came to the conclusion that I'm not actually so much against "Yasu having three (four) different personas/personalities", given the background...
Forum: Umineko 2012-05-13, 15:27
Replies: 34,566
Views: 2,597,121
Posted By Saorin
Well, it's been ages that I've read that Episode,...

Well, it's been ages that I've read that Episode, so I concede that I might only have been under the impression that Will was already aware of the answer by then.
I guess the manga would even imply...
Forum: Umineko 2012-05-13, 08:04
Replies: 34,566
Views: 2,597,121
Posted By Saorin
I'm kinda bored with your "rhetorical" questions,...

I'm kinda bored with your "rhetorical" questions, so I'd prefer not to reply to questions that are apparently aimed at making the other person look "wrong". =D
You're welcome to state what you have...
Forum: Umineko 2012-05-13, 07:56
Replies: 34,566
Views: 2,597,121
Posted By Saorin
If we take it as a reference, you might also...

If we take it as a reference, you might also consider that

a) she can't switch personalities at will, as it seems
b) she doesn't carry over memories from one persona to the other
c) she can't...
Forum: Umineko 2012-05-12, 06:09
Replies: 34,566
Views: 2,597,121
Posted By Saorin
I wholeheartedly agree! Thanks, Jan-Poo. =) ...

I wholeheartedly agree! Thanks, Jan-Poo. =)



Thanks, kylon, the reply is appreciated. I've actually already read your theory there. =)



No, you misunderstand. I never said that it...
Forum: Umineko 2012-05-11, 11:10
Replies: 34,566
Views: 2,597,121
Posted By Saorin
Thanks Jan-Poo, that explanation is appreciated....

Thanks Jan-Poo, that explanation is appreciated. So basically, the meta is the important factor here and the gameboard made to fit that "at any cost" and regardlessly, is that it?

Besides:


I...
Forum: Umineko 2012-05-11, 10:35
Replies: 34,566
Views: 2,597,121
Posted By Saorin
Well, okay, so we can't project anything of that...

Well, okay, so we can't project anything of that to a "realistic" set of events there? It's all rather magical/meta then?
Still, I find the Shkanon-"solution" ridiculous.


Okay, though I...
Forum: Umineko 2012-05-11, 07:45
Replies: 34,566
Views: 2,597,121
Posted By Saorin
Shkanon(trice) died for me as a theory at the...

Shkanon(trice) died for me as a theory at the latest when Will tried to confront Shannon and Kanon at the funeral scene and was denied to do so. :x And I still can't accept it as an satisfying...
Forum: Umineko 2010-12-30, 05:14
Replies: 3,726
Views: 362,652
Posted By Saorin
Aura, I think your solution is quite interesting....

Aura, I think your solution is quite interesting.
But then you don't subscribe to the "Ange's 1998 is the only (real) future" theory, do you? Because if you do, you'd need to explain why nobody ever...
Forum: Umineko 2010-12-29, 15:12
Replies: 3,726
Views: 362,652
Posted By Saorin
I'm sorry, my chances were fifty-fifty and since...

I'm sorry, my chances were fifty-fifty and since it wasn't specified in your profile I just took a guess. =) I now know ;D


Would you then say that that Knox's 1st doesn't even apply in Ep 6? ...
Forum: Umineko 2010-12-29, 14:54
Replies: 3,726
Views: 362,652
Posted By Saorin
Hm? But I was rather referring to the more...

Hm? But I was rather referring to the more popular theories regarding the person Erika, such as Erika is dead or Erika is someone introduced in Ep1-4. I recall Aura mentioning she might represent...
Forum: Umineko 2010-12-29, 13:48
Replies: 3,726
Views: 362,652
Posted By Saorin
Do you mean there is nothing special about...

Do you mean there is nothing special about Erika's existence/appearance or that you are confident you've seen through that?
Forum: Umineko 2010-12-29, 12:49
Replies: 3,726
Views: 362,652
Posted By Saorin
All's possible. I'm just quoting one train of...

All's possible. I'm just quoting one train of thinking, I'm not really set on the Erika problem myself.
Forum: Umineko 2010-12-29, 05:38
Replies: 3,726
Views: 362,652
Posted By Saorin
@Moogleking: Did you read what I posted about...

@Moogleking: Did you read what I posted about Will's comment on the first twilight? Which strongly implied that either Shannon's corpse was never there or someone/thing as disguised as her?
If not,...
Forum: Umineko 2010-12-28, 19:41
Replies: 3,726
Views: 362,652
Posted By Saorin
If you go by the assumption that Will made the...

If you go by the assumption that Will made the correct deductions in Ep7, you'd probably have to go with the first one.

After "battling" Clair, he even says something along the lines of:
"But...
Forum: Umineko 2010-12-28, 19:38
Replies: 3,726
Views: 362,652
Posted By Saorin
But Yasu only seems to make up the description...

But Yasu only seems to make up the description "furniture" to apply to herself after she's complained to Genji and Nanjo about "that body which is unable to love", doesn't she?

Only possible...
Forum: Umineko 2010-12-28, 19:16
Replies: 3,726
Views: 362,652
Posted By Saorin
And I'm still searching for a plausible answer as...

And I'm still searching for a plausible answer as to why Genji is doing it as well.



Again, you're stating this as if it was a fact... Iirc, Gohda was the only servant actually shown dead in...
Forum: Umineko 2010-12-27, 06:45
Replies: 3,726
Views: 362,652
Posted By Saorin
But Gohda... He's seen in the flashback of Ep7...

But Gohda... He's seen in the flashback of Ep7 together with Shannon and Kanon. Genji and Kumasawa are also there, they might acknowledge the personalities as separate entities but I'm not sure why...
Forum: Umineko 2010-12-27, 06:04
Replies: 3,726
Views: 362,652
Posted By Saorin
Yes, I was wondering about that, too. Maybe he...

Yes, I was wondering about that, too. Maybe he wasn't quite set on this. But then again, why didn't it make him press the matter in another way? And he didn't think too much about it afterwards.

...
Forum: Umineko 2010-12-26, 20:29
Replies: 3,726
Views: 362,652
Posted By Saorin
Yeah, I was aware of the fact that it was...

Yeah, I was aware of the fact that it was supposed to show Beatrice wasn't there. But if Lion/Yasu never was at the orphanage, Shannon shouldn't be there either; if we go with the theory that Yasu...
Forum: Umineko 2010-12-26, 20:01
Replies: 3,726
Views: 362,652
Posted By Saorin
Thanks for the answer, Helmet =D Was Dine's...

Thanks for the answer, Helmet =D

Was Dine's 4th one of those stated in red within the game? If not (don't know atm :) ) it is not absolutely certain it does apply to the game, is it? ...
Showing results 1 to 25 of 26

 
Forum Jump

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 00:57.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
We use Silk.