Here I go!
15. Vibeke
-What can I say? Incredible animation and quality. Nice job. It is silky smooth with absolutely no fault that I can see. Quite possibly a rating of 11/10.
18. Evil Rick
-Well, for one thing, Nightmare kicks ass.
For another, I love the crazy colors and it's animated... what more can one ask for in a top-quality signature? You get a 10/10 for presentation, interesting use of color palette, and smooth animation.
36. OceanBlue
-Something about this drew my eye. Probably the bubble shapes. I like the contrast, and sharp, pretty colors (blue is yay!
). I prefer bold colors, and yours really stuck out in my mind. The way you melded together a foreground and background, and stuck the image of the girl in the middle of the two showed skill with layering (and vectoring as well), and proved that it's not just a crop with effects layered on. Easily a 10/10 rating.
Spoiler for some other comments:
If your signature was animated, rest assured I considered it. i know how hard it is to animate anything (I still suck at it), but in the end even if I didn't vote for you, chances are I still thought it was amazing. There was an astonishing number of animated sigs this time around, and you all did wonderful jobs.
One I wanted to mention:
Miko Miko (entry #10): I liked yours A LOT, but in the end I didn't choose it because I found anything wrong with it, but because I just happened to like others a little more. I'm a fan of Chii, and I liked the faded edges, but in the end it was a bit lighter than what I had been looking for a sig. (I would still rate it a 10/10 though)