Quote:
Originally Posted by ijriims
Great. As Erika's perception was accurate and reflects the reality, it is officially crushed then (Though I wonder why it needed an official crushing at all since Shakanon theory never make sense from the real world perspective.)
|
Unfortunately, I think there's still a little wiggle room. Lambda said:
The number of people in this room is the same as the number of people on the island.
And if I remember correctly, the scene wasn't shown from Erika's perspective, so you could argue that it's technically untrustworthy even though Erika was present. Shkanon is like a cockroach
I guess it depends on what the rules for false POVs are. Do all of the participants have to be lying (or dead) to present a false scene, or just the POV character? Battler proposed that a conspiracy was necessary to explain Natsuhi and Kanon talking to Kinzo in the same scene, but that theory wasn't ever confirmed in red.
EDIT: Curses, ninja'd by Jan-poo.