[Marion]

Originally Posted by VecceV

Spoiler for Beatice and Yasu:

What if Yasu is the child of Asumu and Rudolf. And Jessica is Beatice the 3rd.
And Battler is Kyries and Rudolfs son.


Asumu and Kyrie gave birth to live babies and Rudolf gave one to Kinzo. Who gave it to Natsuhi, who pushed it of the cliff. Some time after this Beatice the 2nd gave birth to *Jessica* whom Kinzo gave to Natsuhi. This time she overcome her anger for reasing a child not of her own blood.

After all, Battler and Yasu was born on the same day and Jessica DO look like Beatice the 1st.

Got a tonn of more Arguments and deeper reasoning, but its nearly 6 pm here, so it will have to wait for tomorrow .

Spoiler for Response, Very Minor (no duh) EP 8 Spoilers:

1) The game stated very clearly Yasu is Kinzo and Beatrice II's child. Considering this is stated in EP 7, a game almost entirely devoted to answering Yasu's past, I see no reason for there to be a lie.

2) In EP 8 it's made clear that Asumu had the stillbirth and Rudolf switched the results.

3) It is never stated when Yasu is specifically born. The closest 'birthdate' given is 11/29, which is when Yasu found the gold, but even that isn't a physical birthday.