Quote:
Originally Posted by yononaka
Is it just me or is there some dissonance between your rather strong criticism (which I basically argee with) and your rating of this chapter (9 out of 10)?  I know I personally didn't forget about Raftela, which made the whole "all together now" thing even weirder than it already was. I was tempted to bring her up specifically (and I'm glad you did), but it felt weird to keep raining on the parade of those rejoicing in Miria's survival. (After all, even for you that seems to trump every shortcoming in the end.) I suppose we'll have to assume something fittingly cheesy, like for example she was swayed by the purity of Miria's heart she felt when she manipulated her youki, etc. |
Well, even the worst chapters of Claymore are usually great, and despite the manner in which it happened not being believable to me, I do like Miria, so I am happy to see her back. It didn't get the 10 because it lacked the credibility.