Got scared the forum was going to close for a minute
I'm not familiar with Xenforo, is it very different from vbulletin? I'm really used to the latter by now and I'd hate to lose some functionality. Must have for me is to keep a User CP where you can see threads you've subscribed to, for subscribing to threads to be as easy as it is now, and for there to be a button that leads you to the last unread post. I personally wouldn't mind if the forum stayed as is. It's not like vbulletin isn't supported anymore, right?