AnimeSuki Forum - View Single Post - [Game] Umineko no Naku Koro ni Chiru

ijriims · 2010-02-03, 04:03

An alternative explanation particularly prepared for this 17 people puzzle is to say that Kanon (Yoshiya) was killed by Shannon (Sayo) during the time Battler's group arrived at Rokkenjima and before Erika arrived. (The hint was the dual between Shannon and Kanon)

Genji then gave the codename Kanon to Sayo and himself such that they were Kanon when they were performing Kanon's task. (Kanon and Shannon had been said to be codenames for Rokkenjima's one-wing symbol bearing servants in previous episodes)

The one who saved Battler was Sayo, but because it was initially Kanon's task, Sayo performed this duty so she was Kanon at that time.

When Erika said Kanon was in the wardrobe, Beatrice switched the meaning of Kanon as "a one-wing symbol bearing servant with Kanon as codename" to Kanon as "Yoshiya", so Kanon was not in the wardrobe.

Not involving Shakanon or denying Erika's presence. Does this explanation fare better than the Shakanon theory or "Erika-not a real human" theory?

2010-02-03, 04:03	Link #1275
ijriims Senior Member Join Date: Oct 2009 Location: HK, China	An alternative explanation particularly prepared for this 17 people puzzle is to say that Kanon (Yoshiya) was killed by Shannon (Sayo) during the time Battler's group arrived at Rokkenjima and before Erika arrived. (The hint was the dual between Shannon and Kanon) Genji then gave the codename Kanon to Sayo and himself such that they were Kanon when they were performing Kanon's task. (Kanon and Shannon had been said to be codenames for Rokkenjima's one-wing symbol bearing servants in previous episodes) The one who saved Battler was Sayo, but because it was initially Kanon's task, Sayo performed this duty so she was Kanon at that time. When Erika said Kanon was in the wardrobe, Beatrice switched the meaning of Kanon as "a one-wing symbol bearing servant with Kanon as codename" to Kanon as "Yoshiya", so Kanon was not in the wardrobe. Not involving Shakanon or denying Erika's presence. Does this explanation fare better than the Shakanon theory or "Erika-not a real human" theory? __________________ Kýrie, eléison Battler, you have already known it, right? Without Love, it cannot be seen.