Quote:
Originally Posted by Wanderer
Nope. Anyone could do that one.
Hideyoshi entered the guest room
Hideyoshi did not leave the guest room
Hideyoshi does not exist in the guest room
Hideyoshi is dead.
|
clues? And also how did he do that? in Umineko the only 2 times, someone commited suicide was by either poison or with a winchester... and please... don't come with "
he suffocated himself somehow" or "
he hang himself somehow". And again no clues for poison.
And if a gun was used, Erika would very likely hear it.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Vnonymous
Shkanontrice is essential to Beatrice's solution actually working at all, because otherwise Kanon ends up in the room and what happened is obvious and Mystery wins. Beatrice's solution was most likely something along the lines of "Kanon rescues battler, resets the chain, hides in the closet and then "dies", leaving behind Shannon/Beatrice."
|
Since I firmly believe that "genius Battler" was involved, I am sure that he would not dare to fake himself trapped in a logic error, if shkanontrice didn't exist. Because there still would be 7/8 more deaths of people, he could use then.