View Single Post
Old 2013-08-23, 22:28   Link #355
Shadow5YA
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2010
Quote:
Originally Posted by ReddyRedWolf View Post
If you have not noticed a grail only grants a wish to the letter but not in spirit of the wish.

Shirou wishes for a better world for Miyu. The wish is made by the most practical way. Send Miyu to a parallel universe.

In FSN Kiritsugu wishes for peace. The corrupted grail tells him the best way is that everybody dies.
Shirou explicitly says he wants the world to become a better place. If you are really taking this as what he wished the Grail and not just parting words for Miyu, then it's still different from all the examples you listed.

Kiritsugu still gets peace if no one else is left alive. Miyu's world has not improved one bit. Shirou even states that only half his wish came true.


Quote:
Originally Posted by ReddyRedWolf View Post
If Illya is not human then her mother is not human. Irisviel is still alive and kicking without illness.

That blows away your assertion Illya is a homunculus. That and Illya ages as a normal child.
Are you honestly telling me that a human can contain infinite mana, have complex reasoning and understanding of human language and magecraft at the age of eight months old?

I don't buy it. I can believe she was turned into a normal human with the magic that sealed Kuro away, but it's a big stretch to assume that she has been normal from the very beginning.

Quote:
Originally Posted by ReddyRedWolf View Post
The ritual is incomplete not that it did not happen. The Einzbern already was doing a big ritual. Even Rin managed to dig rumors.

What she did not expect is that it was her hometown and her folks are involved.

It is not the Einzbern ritual. Caren even confirms it. It can't be started other than Irisviel.

The reason why Ruby found this ritual familiar is that Second Magic was happening for some reason.

What is on the world that time in the cave is not what the Einzbern made, it got transported to Miyu's world but it is the area from Miyu's Mt. Enzou.
Wrong. The Einzberns had their own ritual, and there is nothing to suggest that the design was any different. Caren confirms that the ritual Gilgamesh was starting was not the Einzbern's, and it wasn't. Three months ago the Tohsaka's/Einzbern's magic circle under Mt Enzou was switched with the Ainsworth's when Miyu first came over.

Before that (which inclues 10 years ago), it was 100% the Einzbern's ritual.
Shadow5YA is offline   Reply With Quote