|
The problem with your theory is that your theory has no understanding of Beatrice. There is red text saying that she was not involved in the murders and that she is being used as a scapegoat. There is nothing supporting her coming to the island, especially with the limit of 'no more than 17' and the fact that there is a damn typhoon around. The only reason Erika was stated to even get to the island was because she was thrown overboard on a boat and nearly drowned to death if it hadn't been for her life jacket. Your theory conveniently solves everything by blaming it on Beatrice - the one thing that the game has been telling us not to do is to blame Beatrice! Even Ronove snickers at the idea when Battler realizes that there was a human Beatrice that he was prepared to blame everything on.
EP 2's human Beatrice is never seen by Battler until the end of the game, but that scene isn't trustworthy with the golden butterflies and a living Kinzo. You talk about Battler's detective perspective, but fail to mention that there is no proof that what Maria, Rosa, Kyrie and Genji saw was a separate person. Maria is a gullible kid and the other three could easily be lying.
In EP 4 the Beatrice that Battler sees can be a person in disguise. There is no red about anyone being dead at that point, so it isn't hard to imagine that Shannon or Jessica dressed up. The Beatrice that the Suit-Beatrice was talking to could easily be in the latter's own mind, because Battler never sees the former.
And as I already said, EP 6 explains how Meta-Beatrice was created. I'll say right now that it has nothing to do with Lambdadelta or anything of the sort.
As for golden truth, you don't need to be a gamemaster at all. Battler was able to use in in EP 5 for the first time before Lambda appointed him a sorcerer.
|