Down and dirty:
ARENA 01: Amami Haruka
[Elucia de Lute Irma]
ARENA 02:
[Dalian] Ueno Kirika
ARENA 03:
[Inami Mahiru] Iwasawa Asami
ARENA 04:
[Shiina Mayuri] Toshinō Kyōko
ARENA 05: Matsumae Ohana
[Yamada Aoi]
ARENA 06: Mine Riko
[Yune]
ARENA 07:
[Astarotte Ygvar] Haruna
ARENA 08: Ayuzawa Misaki
[Inui Sana]
ARENA 09: Aragaki Ayase
[Uryū Minene]
ARENA 10: Shinonono Hōki
[Wendy Marvell]
ARENA 11:
[Hoshii Miki] Suzutsuki Kanade
ARENA 12: Miki Sayaka
[Shionji Yūko (Alice)]
ARENA 13:
[Anjō Naruko] Shimada Minami
ARENA 14: Nanasaki Ai
[Tomoe Mami]
ARENA 15: Akaza Akari
[Honma Meiko]
ARENA 16:
[Kaga Rin] Shinomiya Ayase
ARENA 17:
[Hanekawa Tsubasa] Lala Satalin Deviluke
ARENA 18: Hoshina Utau
[Izumi Konata]
ARENA 19:
[Erza Scarlet] Saginomiya Isumi
ARENA 20:
[Fujibayashi Kyō] Kuchiki Rukia
ARENA 21:
[Furukawa Nagisa] Haibara Ai
ARENA 22: Sōryū Asuka Langley
[Takamachi Nanoha]
ARENA 23: Hiiragi Tsukasa
[Tsukimiya Ayu]
ARENA 24:
[Kotobuki Tsumugi] Kōzuki Kallen
ARENA 25:
[Chii] Kotegawa Yui
ARENA 26: Hinamori Amu
[Nymph]
ARENA 27:
[Hirasawa Ui] Kagura
ARENA 28:
[Kushieda Minori] Uiharu Kazari
ARENA 29: Alice
[Okazaki Ushio]
ARENA 30: Hanato Kobato
[Hecate]
ARENA 31:
[Ichinose Kotomi] Isayama Yomi
ARENA 32:
[Suiseiseki] Tainaka Ritsu
Miki Sayaka vs Alice went back and forth until the moe factor tipped the scales for Alice
Able to vote for my fave major and minor leaguers so it's all good
