Quote:
Originally Posted by battle22
Guy's in EP3 2nd twilight (Maria and Rosa in the rose garden)
"Earth to earth. ......No falsehoods in their final moments as told."
Yasu is the only possible culprit here right?
6 people: Kinzo, Genji, Shannon, Kanon, Gohda, and Kumasawa are dead!
Also Shannon and Kanon are dead ,It doesn't mean yasu is dead too right?
Since she can revive and kill shannon and kanon. and i haven't read ep8 yet so please tell me if there's a red saying that yasu is not the culprit.
However It is forbidden for a servant to be the culprit!! so yasu is not the culprit? or shannon and kanon can't be the culprit's but yasu can ,becouse she's not a servant ?
PS.SORRY IF I DIDN"T MAKE ANY SENSE.
|
Besides Yasu, Rudolf and Eva don't have alibis either, and since Maria and Rosa weren't said to have been killed by the same people, either of them could have killed the other as well. You also have little details like the victims not being staked and the gun being left behind which suggest that this wasn't a normal twilight murder. We at least know that Eva snuck out of her room and arranged a false alibi with Hideyoshi, so you have to account for that as well.
There's a couple of different scenarios you can build. Here's one where Eva is innocent:
Maria has been told to lure Rosa out to the garden for a meeting with Beatrice. Not realizing this, Rosa tries to pretend she's been possessed by Beatrice so she can extract information. Maria is fooled for a moment, but then she sees through it and flips out. Rosa starts to strangle her in a fit of rage. At that moment, Yasu arrives for the meeting, sees what's happening, and runs over to save Maria. In the ensuing struggle, she accidentally pushes Rosa onto the fence and kills her. She flees in despair after realizing that Maria is already dead. A short time later, Eva sneaks out of her room to discuss the gold with Rosa and discovers both of the corpses. Now she doesn't have an alibi for their deaths, so she runs back to the guesthouse and explains everything to Hideyoshi, who agrees to cover for her.
You can make another where Maria just wanted to see the rose, and Eva is the one who tries to stop the strangling. In that scenario, Yasu doesn't enter the situation at all.