|
Are you supposing that Erika existed on Rokkenjima in the reality of R-Prime, then?
How's this for example - a tale is written, Bath of the Golden Witch, wherein it's described that Jessica has a bitchin' hot tub in her bedroom that she and the servants like to use, occasionally. Let's say it serves no purpose to the mystery, but is there, and maybe there's a fanservicey scene of Jessica using it.
Clearly, this is stupid - Jessica probably didn't really have a hot tub in her room. But you can write a story where that is the case, and it's intended to be accepted by the reader as reality, not a fantasy scene. However, the Witch Hunters basically call bullshit on you, and disregard this tale, because Word of God on the matter has been inconsistent. Ryukishi shows us a particularly egregious example of this with 'End'.
|