[theacefrehley]

Originally Posted by kgptzac

Spoiler:

ok i think i gathered enough information to make up my rather arrogant theory.
For some reason I find Beatrice to be a badass version of Hanyuu
The rest would be easy. Either the 19th person hiding in Eva and Hideyoshi's room waiting for them or knocking the door to get in. If Hideyoshi was taking a bath it was way too easy to shoot ice picks at their heads. If I remember things correctly, the chain is not a reliable proof of a enclosed room because there are several ways to fake it. It is also possible for Kinzo to come and kill the couple with an ice pick shooter... although I don't his health permits it. It also could have been any other Ushiromiya...

Your theory makes sense
But
That part definitely doesn't
They, mainly Battler, insist that the chain IS a reliable way to make an enclosed space

And besides,
If I'm not mistaken, Genji supervised the construction of the mansion and until the end he said there's no secret passage.

I think that by the situation they were in the last 2 chapters, if he really knew a secret passage, he would blurt it out already. It was obvious that someone was out there killing everybody. Unless he believed he would be spared


But your theory leaves room for lots of combinations in future chapters since there are no murderers-wannabe inside the family at first arriving in the island

Originally Posted by Sterling01

Spoiler for Rudolf:

Since I believe in Beatrice I still think it's her doing and Rudolf says he might be killed not will be killed

Whatever,
It doesn't make any difference
It just implies that Rudolf is up to/on something