AnimeSuki Forum - View Single Post - sola - Overall Series Impressions & Total Series Rating

Mirrinus · 2007-07-03, 12:02

I rated this series a "7". I've actually decided to eat my words from before and start using an actual larger-scale scoring system, divided into 8 categories of differing weight. Total maximum possible score is 100 points. Sola receives a 66/100.

As I've said before in the episode 13 thread, the series was enjoyable when viewed casually, but when I scrutinize and look deeper, it doesn't really impress very much. It was still worth my time (mostly for Takeshi and Mayuko), but there were many things that were disappointing and could have been better, and those really do add up.

Much longer write-up and explanation of my scores for each category coming up, when I actually get home and take a look at my notes (and tear myself away from playing EFZ). This will be the first series that I've used such a method to determine my initial rating (I tested this rating system on Kanon 2006, but I had already rated that prior).

Edit: finally got my notes

2007-07-03, 12:02	Link #7
Mirrinus Bemused Scholar Join Date: Jan 2007 Age: 36	I rated this series a "7". I've actually decided to eat my words from before and start using an actual larger-scale scoring system, divided into 8 categories of differing weight. Total maximum possible score is 100 points. Sola receives a 66/100. As I've said before in the episode 13 thread, the series was enjoyable when viewed casually, but when I scrutinize and look deeper, it doesn't really impress very much. It was still worth my time (mostly for Takeshi and Mayuko), but there were many things that were disappointing and could have been better, and those really do add up. Much longer write-up and explanation of my scores for each category coming up, when I actually get home and take a look at my notes (and tear myself away from playing EFZ). This will be the first series that I've used such a method to determine my initial rating (I tested this rating system on Kanon 2006, but I had already rated that prior). Edit: finally got my notes Last edited by Mirrinus; 2007-07-06 at 01:01.