Excellent points.
I've heard that Lee only learned the first form and maybe part of the second -- could very well be wrong, though. And he's not around to tell us.
Disagree. There are two schools of thought (three if you count mixed-martial arts):
- "All fights go to the ground -- learn how to fight there."
- "All fights start standing -- keep them there."
- "Be prepared to fight standing or on the ground. (Note that if you train both equally, you will excel at neither -- which is a conveniently forgotten fact.)"
I already said this before in the thread -- I would avoid the ground at all costs in a fight. When you're standing, you can still run away.
No style teaches you how to take a chair shot except for WWF-style, if you smell what the Rock is cooking.
And no teacher worth anything will train you to counter "Eagle Dives to Pick Plum Blossom" with "Phoenix Ascends to the Heavens" or any such thing.
If there's a punch coming at your head --
any punch -- you have to either:
- Block it
- Parry it
- Avoid it
- Get socked in the face
Martial arts drills will train your body to instinctively do one of them. If you learn no style, or do not drill, you'll take too much time considering what to do, and end up getting socked in the face. That's really all martial arts are.