[Judoh]

Getting a few points out of the way. Because I can. Ah well.

Originally Posted by Roseweave

There's a similar set of problems with Shkannontrice.

The room thing is still a valid point. They comment that it would normally go 2 and 2. Yasu is in a one person room while they're in a three person room, and that would only make sense if the Shannon isn't really staying in Yasu's room.

Plus, your theory screws up Shannon's timeline. Which, despite my earlier response is sort of a pet peeve of mine. Besides Battler's timeline she's the only other person that's had her timeline emphasized as being important through out well... A LOT of the plot.

Fans came up with that.

Just like you have.

And it's not true that she wasn't seen by anyone - after all there were plenty of sightings of Beatrice around the mansion.

But none that necessitates that there must be two people instead of one. You're actually creating more unnecessary assumptions.

Shkannontrice is just a truly awful theory.

Some people don't agree with this.