|
You are actually acting like George and the rest back in the first tea party: because there isn't any immediate explanations about one's death, it "becomes" the witch doing.
However, there is no definite truth to explain everything, but the underlying assumption is: since there are so many possible explanations behind these cases, it is pretty much leaving too much room for an oversimple "magic" explanation.
Kanon: as much people already figured out, there is no proof regarding "Jessica's key" authenticity. Therefore, there is no need of a Master Key for this case (and if we aren't as naive as Battler, nothing prevents us to suspect Gohda or Kumasawa).
Likewise, there is no proof Kanon "really" died if Beatrice used a word play (although I'm not fan of this speculation).
If we speculate the whole scene was a giant delusion by Kanon (who is overly loyal to Kinzo), it is possible to explain the fancy show.
Likewise, there is nothing that settle Shannon's death either.
For all intent and purpose: from a author point of view, it would be suicide and meaningless if the answer is "the witch", because it wouldn't require any thought process for the solution.
Furthermore, once again, there ARE inconsistencies:
First: why did the "witch" kill people despite the alibis aren't clear enough? Why didn't she show up before them? And so forth and so forth.
|