Quote:
Originally Posted by Patchwork Chimera
You know why Battler's death has nothing to do with those rules? Because that's what happened in the world outside the catbox. No red texts, no magic, no 'gameboard rules' and certainly no 'character death'. That, as far as Umineko as a whole was concerned, happened outside Rokkenjima's mistery, 'In real Life' so to speak. He got brain damage. He stopped believing himself Battler. Arguably, he got better after some decades. Calling it 'personality death' like in-gameboard is just pulling an Irony as a Name.
|
Right, so, you just proved the utter stupidity of even discussing Battler's death in red. Which means... wait, what
are you talking about? Because Battler's idiotic stupid amnesia only even works in that context.
Shouldn't we be applying
greater realistic scrutiny to something not inside the catbox?
Basically you're completely incoherent.