the only issue i have with your sig is the fact the guy kinda blends into your background. though I doubt I could give good advice since I think I suck at Photoshop
XD
I don't really like the other sig so I guess its just going down to personal preference on that other website
I like both Malin 8/10 little on the small side but i am really liking the style
Matterlajn 8/10 again like the style but small.
I guess nothing can be done about that though with the current file size restrictions