AnimeSuki Forum - View Single Post - Character Discussion

Tael · 2008-09-30, 13:19

Where is this 50/50 coming from? Stop trying to be statisticians and making up statistics. He died, visibly, on screen. The highest probability is that he is dead, the probability that he is alive is brought forth by people grasping at possible scenarios of explanation, none of which fly all that far without people putting severe holes into the theory.

Activation on death theory -> Charles was never shown to be affected by Lelouch's Geass before shooting himself, after acquiring the code. As such, there is more basis to the idea that, since the Geass animation was missing, that he was no Geassed and that his immortality was immediately activated upon acquiring V.V.'s code.

Charles Code -> Plausible, but falls to its knees in light of the fact that he had his Geass and that the activation on death theory has a rather large hole in its face.

The driver was oddly cut out -> Or maybe, the focus wasn't on the driver, it was on the crane that was in the middle of the screen as the shot pans up... no couldn't be that, had to be the driver.

Do I actually care? No. I can take either possibility, but stop making up numbers.

2008-09-30, 13:19	Link #3058
Tael Banned Join Date: Sep 2008 Location: Internet	Where is this 50/50 coming from? Stop trying to be statisticians and making up statistics. He died, visibly, on screen. The highest probability is that he is dead, the probability that he is alive is brought forth by people grasping at possible scenarios of explanation, none of which fly all that far without people putting severe holes into the theory. Activation on death theory -> Charles was never shown to be affected by Lelouch's Geass before shooting himself, after acquiring the code. As such, there is more basis to the idea that, since the Geass animation was missing, that he was no Geassed and that his immortality was immediately activated upon acquiring V.V.'s code. Charles Code -> Plausible, but falls to its knees in light of the fact that he had his Geass and that the activation on death theory has a rather large hole in its face. The driver was oddly cut out -> Or maybe, the focus wasn't on the driver, it was on the crane that was in the middle of the screen as the shot pans up... no couldn't be that, had to be the driver. Do I actually care? No. I can take either possibility, but stop making up numbers.