Shuffle! gets an 8 for me, the ending of the kaede arc could have been alot better and I thought it was leading up to something a bit more then just a calm little chat between kaede and Asa given what happened the night before...
The Asa arc could have been better... probly would have been if I didnt hit those damned spoiler tags
Since its not human nature to blame ones self im holding all of you responsible!
This series would have been a 7.5 if I can use decimals but I decided that the extra .5 was worth it to me because its not the childhood friend that wins this time