View Single Post
Old 2007-12-18, 14:16   Link #31
Fervor
Junior Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2007
Quote:
Originally Posted by ironbomb View Post
You dont have to stab someone to kill them. His actions where enough to kill Kotonoha and Sekai, even the baby she was baring. Ill keep saying this over and over if I must, by neglecting his responsibilities of being a father and boyfriend he is slowly killing Sekai off. He might not have "directly" STABBED her but every action he has done/taken SIMILAR to stab to her heart/body. What Matoko doing might even be consider worst than a murderer since he is SLOW TORTURING her to death.
Let's make something very clear. Never, ever did he intend to kill anyone. He didn't intend to torture Sekai either. There is no intent at all. It's not the same thing. How Sekai felt is a consequence of his insensitivity and selfishness, but you cannot argue intent.

If you stab someone with a knife, there is very clear intent to kill. The only question is whether it's premediated or not.

It is the biggest difference in the world. Makoto did not intend to rape, kill or torture anyone. You cannot argue otherwise. No court or judge would even punish him for what he did.

Are his actions ethically and morally questionable? Of course. But there is no law anywhere that says that any of his actions should be punished.
Fervor is offline