Quote:
Originally Posted by Wilfriback
Oh well, thats my interpretation =_=+
|
Didn't mean to nitpick
... that's perfectly fine then.
Quote:
|
Thats what I'm saying guiilt. It include envy of course but I give equal or more weight to the guilt because if Madoka now lives a normal life Homura herself isn't included on Madoka's life.
|
Please explain that to me... why "guilt" of all feelings?
In my theoretical scenario, the Homura of the past cared deeply for Madoka the MG, and she saw that Madoka was suffering due to her open, caring nature. So she decides to essentially take Madoka's burden and become a MG in her stead. As her wish, she chooses "Let Madoka live the life of a normal girl in a loving family, unknowing of the whole MG business".
In doing so, Homura implicitly forfeited any hope for gratitude or companionship. Instead, she'd rather even lose contact to the person dear to her, FOR HER SAKE.
Now explain to me: Why would Homura feel _guilt_ about doing this? Guilt implies wrongdoing. It would rather have been a gold-hearted sacrifice she could be proud of.