The Ranka version is better but mainly because of the live vibe to it with the different instruments and the crowd clapping just added to that greatly. Switch the vocalists (they would obviously sing differently with the situations reversed) and I doubt it would change my opinion in that the Formo version is better. Ranka version is like a 5/5 while Sheryl is a 4/5 just off what I've heard in the anime.. who knows the full vesions from the OST might make me like the Sheryl version better. I really dig the Sharon Apple type vibe in that song..
|