Quote:
Originally Posted by NoirX
What I mean is, that it's true that Kirito's purpose of being on UW is to make the AIs learn to disobey, but that is only to the extent of the specific rules of killing other humans are forbidden. Because from RATH's perspective the only "defective" result is the obedience in not killing other humans. Other than that, the RATH still wants to put the AIs on a leash which would make them into an obedient killing drone.
|
But learning doesn't work that way. These AIs are sentient, they learn like humans, so they can't learn to disobey just one specific rule. That's ridiculous.
What they're ultimately learning from Kirito is a general free will: to think by themselves instead of obeying rules (any rule) blindly, and choose accordingly. Basically, to be humans.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Adigard
To be fair... the exact same thing can be said in regards to a human pilot. Apparently a lot of nation's are capable of raising people willing to lay down their lives for their fellow countrymen, all throughout history. So there's probably some way to do it for AI's as well.
|
Yeah, but humans are paid, and they have rights and laws protecting those rights. AIs have nothing like that. Or are they going to give AIs all that? I doubt it, and even if they do, that itself would be a totally different Pandora Box to deal with.
So no, that whole ideal is full of holes.