Ao no Exorcist - nice action, school life, fun chara, romance level similar to Index.
Busou Renkin - more serious series with better developed romance.
Fullmetal Alchemist - not school life but has everything you want. Brotherhood probably will be more to your liking.
Full Metal Panic - if you don't mind mecha. Fumoffu os great comedy with some action bits.
Ga-Rei Zero if you don't mind something more serious and dramatic and female as MC. School life, some nice battles, Yomi is a very memorable MC.
Hunter x Hunter - not school life but something you could definitely enjoy. The new 2011 version could be more to your liking but you can try old one too.
Katekyo Hitman Reborn! - didn't like it but could fit your taste too since it has school life, quiet fun battles and... well MC is debatable. You could like him.
Mai-HiME - if you don't mind females doing most of the fighting. Good mix of comedy and drama. Nice action and some very memorable characters.
Soul Eater - could work.
Toaru Kagaku no Railgun - side series of Index that mostly focus on Misaka if you haven't seen them yet.
|