Quote:
Originally Posted by Sabaku Kyu
The Uchica weren't murdered because of the Kyuubi attack...this is the reason they were segregated. The clan was killed because they were planning a coup against Konoha. And there was really no need for a trial because there was no doubt about their conspiracy. Sandaime actually tried to negotiate with the Uchiha through diplomacy. When that failed, Danzou and the Elders took matters into their own hands--or rather put it into Itachi's hands.
I agree with that, though I'll admit Itachi was in a really desperate situation. From what it seems like, the Uchiha were pretty adamant about rebelling against Konoha. There's no telling what would've happened had the coup actually happened.
But at best, I would consider Itachi a victim.
|
How can itachi be put in a really desperate situation and made a victim? He decided to put himself as the victim. There could be other options to prevent the massacre and have him take control of the clan instead, although we do not know if that's possible or not, but it sounds alot better than mass genocide and turning your beloved sibling into a vengeful-driven psycho
Itachi knew about the presence of Tobi/madara and instead of warning the Leaf village, he stayed silent. This seems noble at first, forcing Tobi to promise not to attack the village, but the best time the village/ninja world had to stop his plan/the 4th war would have been back then, probably warn the Uchiha & or the village elders about Tobi, the man RESPONSIBLE for the 9 tails rampage on the village. Before he had gathered the akatsuki/made money/killed & sealed the jinchuriki & bijuu/grew the 100,000 zetsu clone army.
Shisui and Itachi, which were known as one of the strongest genjutsu users among Uchiha (probably the strongest), should be able to convince Uchiha elders via their normal Sharingan genjutsu to avoid war and try to negotiate with Hiruzen even without using of Kotoamatsukami (and probably Shisui should be able to do maximum two of those per 10 years, unless he got Hashirama's cells).
If possible, Itachi could've taken his father's place of Uchiha leader by challenging him for the rule of the clan. If he would prove himself stronger than any other of his clan (and only Shisui at that time had MS and he has only extreme powerful Genjutsu and was Itachi's supporter) than with him in control of his clan he would be able to stop this pointless bloodshed. I think the hokage or the elders could allow that to happen, have an Uchiha on their side and that Uchiha is leader of the clan to keep the clan in check.
No one understands why Itachi massacred his family. He never said why and we can hardly trust the word of Tobi a habitual liar. The Uchiha were not fooled by Tobi, the Leaf were fooled by Tobi, something Itachi forgot to mention to the elders about (a person who did have the power to control the fox and frame the Uchiha, important information, yes)Tobi/madara being alive. He joined to spy, but his actions helped the 4th ninja war to happen, and he was a shitty spy. Who did he give any information to? He created war joining akatsuki. People talk about his supposed intentions, while his actions say something totally different. What did he do to counteract all the evil he did? probably the only good thing he ever did was to leave Naruto alone (didn't capture the 9 tails, his original mission in akatsuki), and now here is Naruto cleaning up after his mess .
Itachi endangered Konoha worst of all he made the weapon that Sasuke has become, armed him with MS/EMS, allowed Tobi to tell him the Truth/maybe, Itachi killed the uchiha and let Sasuke feel guilt for killing him to fuel his hate/sadness.