View Single Post
Old 2011-01-21, 22:45   Link #21631
AuraTwilight
The True Culprit
 
 
Join Date: Oct 2010
Location: The Golden Land
Send a message via AIM to AuraTwilight Send a message via MSN to AuraTwilight
Quote:
You know I am not so sure about that Beatrice the First is pure Italian, if we believe the portrait is of Beatrice the Second (and or the First) then she is blond hair, too despite being only half Italian blood, then if that logic follow, Beatrice the Second's daughter would have blond hair, too. Clair who had white hair is just a trick Bernkastel comes up with and Clair is not what Yasu really look like unless you assumes she inherit Kinzo's hair.
Well, if Battler is any indication, Kinzo had red hair as a kid. Moreover, blonde hair is a very passive gene. It's enough of a miracle that it showed up in Beatrice 2, it's very unlikely it'd show up again (which is another reason why Lion would be a miracle that Yasuda doesn't have, I guess). If Yasuda's hair is blonde, then she must have been wearing a wig at almost all times, because there is no way in hell that it would've been ignored, especially after the painting was put up.

We know the Claire appearance is something Yasuda came up with, not Bern, because Asune mentions seeing a figure with white hair and a white dress hanging around in the Special VIP Room. And obviously, it's not Yasuda's natural haircolor, and it's certainly too long away. She uses wigs, we can't ignore this fact.

Quote:
What if I turn the chessboard around and say that because Battler saw how beautiful Yasu is due to her Italian blood (blond hair, blue eyes) and she is also a mystery novel nut like he was, he falls in love with her and she then becomes his ideal woman. That would also be possible, isn't it?
Well, neither Yasuda or Lion have blue eyes, and when Battler mentions his ideal woman, he specifically references "busty blonde babes like in Hollywood movies." He doesn't give any indication that Yasuda is an influence. Especially with the crass personality thing.

Face it, she's not blonde.

Quote:
About Yasu multiple personality disorder if we assume what Yasu said in Ep7 is true minus the part looking like Shannon or Kanon because she cannot change her appearance, disguising does not make sense imaging that she would have to convince everyone who live in the mansion to believe that Shannon and Yasu are in 2 different human bodies. Don't forget she was pretty young when she starts working in the mansion, then do you think a 9 year-old-kid is clever enough to think 10 years ahead of time how she gonna deceive everyone to carry her vengeance (in the real story, I would like to think that she was used by Kyrie to commit those murder before getting fed up with it and run away with Battler or Battler rescues her and then they jump off the cliff to be together in death but Battler survive)
Well, she wasn't nine. By the time she created Shannon and Kanon, she was about seventeen or so ("Shannon", that is, "Sayo", is implied to be her default appearance/name/whatever). Moreover, Yasu doesn't really show any signs of multiple personality disorder, or even "vengeance against the family." She's just ACTING. She's playing pretend and cosplaying, wanting to perform "magic" by convincing people that her characters are real people.
__________________
When the Silent Spirits Cry: An Umineko/Silent Hill crossover fanfiction
http://forums.animesuki.com/showpost.php?p=4565173&postcount=531
AuraTwilight is offline   Reply With Quote