[Avisch]

Spoiler for Theory behind the death made 'impossible' because of red text:

Eva-Beatrice claims that the 15 persons are dead by counting up all their names. But if I remember right, she never said that there were 15 dead people on the island. This leaves me with the theory of a doppelganger. If a person named Ingrid kills Rosa takes her identity before coming to the island, Eva-Beatrice can claim that Rosa is dead while Ingrid is still walking around and could kill Nanjo. This isn't of course limited to one person.

I also made this theory instead it revolved around Kinzo.

MY post from page 42

Spoiler for Theory:

When she says There are 18 people on this Rokkenjima. Of course, first we can point out "this" as only specifying the Rokkenjima in this Episode, therefore saying that the red-text only applies

However, what is the definition of a "person" to the red text? Because let's say.

Kinzo imposter shows up before the reunion. Kills real Kinzo. Real Kinzo is now no longer considered a "person" by the game if he is dead. The imposter takes his place, 18 people is still maintained.

Then this does not contradict the red text when Kinzo's death is confirmed, and body present is indeed Kinzo's.


But I can see this theory being easily overridden. If "person" is considered "a body living or dead" by the red text.

Spoiler for Here are my thoughts about the 'new witch':

My theory is that the birth of Eva-Beatrice is a metaphor for the birth of a new killing intent.

I also agree with this.

Spoiler for idea and Higurashi comparison:

Perhaps it might turn out more complicated.

But yes I think Beato represents the killer
And with Eva-Beatrice, and then Eva being revealed as the killer. It goes hand in hand right?

Ultimately I think we are being presented with a situation similar to Watanagashi/Meakashi from Higurashi. Cause the killer in those murders was definitely not the final one.