[Rurik]

Originally Posted by chuckcsf

So you don't know if it's worse or better... well comon sense dictates (mine atleast) that it was worse since they are having a hard time already even with Kakashi. With this fact, it is safe to conclude that Shika's previous plan would have caused his team to be wiped out since I don't think Kakashi could make his plan a worse plan. Yes the strategy changed but it was a good change. If it was a bad change... then that means Shika is not that good of a strategist if he made a bad change. If it is a good change in strategy then his previous plan sucked.

And I agree with you as an Opinion that with Kakashi it should has been a much better and a plan with a hihger succes rate..

My point is (and I guess is what Saze was talking about) that even if he made a better strategy with Kakashi, that doesn't mean the previous one without him was doomed, and that even this one with kakashi need Help of people not in the plan (maybe), So, talking about plot wise, without kakashi, something similar would had happened and at the precise moment get saved by others but not until part of Shikas plans ot completed up to the end (like what Happened with Tayuya).

Which makes me think, could Shika have tough about reinforcement as part of the Plan?