[Slayerx]

Can we keep in mind that this thread ISN'T a manga thread... honestly, spoilers poeple, spoilers...

as for Garp

Spoiler:

Well if i recall correctly, the manga never said that Garp actually captured roger, but that he cornered him many times... you could say that garp is to roger as smoker is too Luffy... chases him down but he always slipped between his figers... ok, so smoker has yet to catch up to luffy since alabasta, but you get my point (what's up with that?)

I'd also give roger some more credit than that... he had one of the most powerful ships ever built... i somehow doubt that his ship and crew (who would defend the ship) would have been stopped by JUST cannon ball-like attacks...