View Single Post
Old 2009-09-27, 18:22   Link #3525
Jan-Poo
別にいいけど
 
 
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: forever lost inside a logic error
Quote:
Originally Posted by KanonTheFurniture View Post
I know the two were once friendly cousins when they met in real life during the conferences. However, I don't remember this being mentioned at all. As I understood it, the game never mentioned anything about the real Ange telling the real Maria when they were little girls on Rokkenjima that she denied magic. The way it seemed was as though the first time Ange denied magic was that time in the classroom, where she was denying it to the witch Maria, the Maria who had already died in the real world during the incident. It's even said pretty clearly when she first talks to Maria through the diary (by which I mean the first time we see it in the game, not the first chronological time she did it) that the Maria she's speaking to is dead in the real world. So that means this Maria she speaks to is the Maria who already died, IE, post Rokkenjima Incident.

And that scene where she denied them in the classroom was a flashback scene, so now in the present of 1998, as Ange is making her journey to Rokkenjima having made up with the Stakes and Sakutaro, she's remembering having hurt them like that in the past. But I don't remember anything being said about the time she denied magic and witches being when Ange and Maria were little girls...are you sure about this? I wrote my previous post after a few hours marathoning until that scene and I absolutely do not remember anything being said about it happening like that. I'm not saying you guys are wrong - like I said, the constant flashbacks really confused me - but I don't remember this being said anywhere. Can someone point it out clearly?

Quote:
Maria onee-chan, you're we-ird!! There is no Sakutaro-! Stuffed animals are stuffed anima-ls!

I learned from Mama that they're made of cloth and co-tton!! There's no way they can walk or ta-lk!! *giggle*giggle*, *giggle*giggle*giggle*!!!
Denying Sakutaro is like denying magic. By refusing Sakutaro's existence Ange denied magic as well. If she really acknowledge Maria as a witch she would also acknowledge the existence of Sakutaro. Maria is the witch of origin. So I don't think it is necessary to search for an explicit sentence where Ange actually said Maria is not a witch, considering she denied her power. It is implicit.

Anyway when Ange said that she hurt Maria, she referred to that event.
__________________

Jan-Poo is offline   Reply With Quote